The fluid definition of the ‘waters of the United States’: Non‐uniform effects of regulation on US wetland protections
- 6 November 2022
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Hydrological Processes
- Vol. 36 (11)
Abstract
Recent revisions to the definition of the ‘waters of the United States’ (WOTUS) have considerably altered how wetlands are federally regulated under the Clean Water Act. The two most recent modifications to WOTUS, the Clean Water Rule (CWR) and the Navigable Waters Protection Rule (NWPR), represent two opposing approaches to the federal wetland policy. The impacts of these two rules on the regulation of wetlands have as of yet been poorly characterized at broad spatial scales. Using New York State (NYS) as a case study, we evaluated the jurisdictional statuses of more than 253 000 wetlands under the CWR and the NWPR to assess the landscape‐scale effects of WOTUS re‐definitions. We found that statewide and within each of NYS's hydrologic regions, the NWPR protects fewer wetlands and less total wetland area than the CWR. The efficacy of the two regulations varied considerably in space across NYS, highlighting the need for comprehensive, nationwide assessments of wetland policy outcomes. We also observed that both rules produced non‐uniform patterns in jurisdiction across a range of landscape positions and wetland sizes, preferentially protecting large wetlands close to the stream network. This effect was particularly pronounced under the NWPR, which excludes all geographically isolated wetlands from protection. Our findings in NYS emphasize the existence of unique patterns in protected wetlands across spatial scales, highlighting the value in applying geospatial analyses to evaluate environmental policy.Keywords
All Related Versions
Funding Information
- National Science Foundation of Sri Lanka
- U.S. Department of Agriculture
- U.S. Department of Energy
This publication has 36 references indexed in Scilit:
- How much wetland has the world lost? Long-term and recent trends in global wetland areaMarine and Freshwater Research, 2014
- Biogeochemical Hotspots in Forested Landscapes: The Role of Vernal Pools in Denitrification and Organic Matter ProcessingEcosystems, 2014
- Dynamic, discontinuous stream networks: hydrologically driven variations in active drainage density, flowing channels and stream orderHydrological Processes, 2014
- Differential Assessment of Designations of Wetland Status Using Two Delineation MethodsEnvironmental Management, 2014
- Potential Stream Density in Mid-Atlantic U.S. WatershedsPLOS ONE, 2013
- How Wetlands Affect FloodsWetlands, 2013
- Values of natural and human‐made wetlands: A meta‐analysisWater Resources Research, 2010
- Simulated environmental effects of wetland restoration scenarios in a typical Canadian prairie watershedWetlands Ecology and Management, 2009
- Small habitat size and isolation can promote species richness: second‐order effects on biodiversity in shallow lakes and pondsOikos, 2006
- Flood Reduction through Wetland Restoration: The Upper Mississippi River Basin as a Case HistoryRestoration Ecology, 1995