Abstract
Digital policy evaluations typically focus on observed outcomes while giving less attention to the intentions articulated in policy discourse. Consequently, such evaluations may reflect unintended consequences, potentially resulting in misleading policy recommendations. This study examines whether smart city pilot (SCP) initiatives can be conceptualized as a human-centered digital policy by bridging policy discourse and outcomes. Achieving this requires a consistent measure of human-centeredness, which is defined using the principle of inclusiveness in this study. Human-centered digital technology (HDT), as reflected in both policy discourse and observable outcomes, is designed to embody the inclusiveness of digitalization. The corresponding human-centered outcomes for citizens are captured through a novel welfare index that measures inclusive income growth. Drawing on a staggered difference-in-differences approach and data from the China Family Panel Studies (CFPS) (2010–2018), the results show that SCPs significantly improved welfare, as well as their key components—income levels and equity. The results indicate that advances in HDT constitute a central mechanism through which SCP translates into welfare effects. Moreover, applying large language models to policy discourse analysis reveals that SCPs heightened the government’s emphasis on HDT, which further facilitates observable HDT development. These findings suggest that SCPs can be conceptualized as human-centered digital policies, both in terms of their discourse-based intentions and observable outcomes. This study contributes to multiple strands of literature by developing a comprehensive framework bridging discursive and empirical evidence.