Abstract
This interesting study by Ulvik et al. compared the performance of two lasers for the treatment of upper urinary tract stones by retrograde intrarenal surgery (RIRS). One group used a 30W Holmium:yttrium-aluminum-garnet (Ho:YAG) laser and the other group a 60W Thulium fiber laser (TFL). Both groups started with similar lasing parameters, but it was allowed for the surgeon to change them during surgery. TFL was found to be superior regarding surgical time and stone-free rate. Some limitations of the study should be pointed out: 1) its single center design, 2) laser settings could be modified during surgery, and 3) probably the most important limitation was that laser power for Ho:YAG was half of the TFL. There is no comment in the article about how the sample size was calculated. An other study with a high power Ho:YAG laser didn’t observe the same differences between both groups {1}.