Lack of adoption of computational gene-panel-selection tools in targeted spatial transcriptomics
Preprint
Abstract
Targeted spatial transcriptomics requires selecting a gene panel before any experiment is run. Choosing well across tens of thousands of candidate genes under platform-specific probe, panelsize, and sensitivity constraints is difficult to do manually, and impossible to correct once a panel has been used. A growing number of computational tools to automate this selection have been designed, yet it remains unclear whether they are adopted in practice. Several factors could limit uptake: validation uncertainty about panel performance, workflow friction between a ranked gene list and a submission-ready panel, limited platform awareness in tools developed for dissociated single-cell data, and the cost advantage of vendor panels. We analyzed 18 computational tools for gene-panel selection from two angles: their citation landscape and their use across a targeted spatial transcriptomics corpus. Across 540 full-text-classified records, only 35 (6.5%) reported using the cited tool for panel design; most came from computational, benchmark, review, or non-spatial papers, or papers that cited but did not use it. In an independent corpus, only 34 of 479 (7.1%) involved a computational tool, alone or in a hybrid workflow; most used manually curated, premade vendor, or modified vendor panels. Both lines of evidence point the same way: computational selection is rarely part of the reported experimental workflow, and it more often supplemented manual curation than replaced it. Adoption is unlikely to turn on further benchmark gains alone; it will depend on reducing the validation uncertainty and workflow friction that keep users on established panel-design practice.Keywords
This publication has 36 references indexed in Scilit:
- High resolution mapping of the tumor microenvironment using integrated single-cell, spatial and in situ analysisNature Communications, 2023
- Predictive and robust gene selection for spatial transcriptomicsNature Communications, 2023
- scMAGS: Marker gene selection from scRNA-seq data for spatial transcriptomics studiesComputers in Biology and Medicine, 2023
- Hybridization Chain Reaction Fluorescence In Situ Hybridization (HCR-FISH) in Ambystoma mexicanum Tissue2022
- High-plex imaging of RNA and proteins at subcellular resolution in fixed tissue by spatial molecular imagingNature Biotechnology, 2022
- EASI-FISH for thick tissue defines lateral hypothalamus spatio-molecular organizationCell, 2021
- Optimal marker gene selection for cell type discrimination in single cell analysesNature Communications, 2021
- Systematic benchmarking of omics computational toolsNature Communications, 2019
- Transcriptome-scale super-resolved imaging in tissues by RNA seqFISH+Nature, 2019
- In situ sequencing for RNA analysis in preserved tissue and cellsNature Methods, 2013