Lichenometric Dating and Its Limitations and Problems: A Guide for Practitioners
Open Access
Abstract
Lichenometry, a method for dating rock surface exposure mainly in high latitudes and mountain environments, is based on estimates of lichen growth rates, but over the last 70 years it has been severely criticised. Its chief limitation is its questionable reliability due to three main problems: the species belonging to the Rhizocarpon subgenus, most often used by lichenometrists, are hard to identify; growth studies have highlighted the intrinsic variability of growth both seasonally and annually, with species sensitively responding to a wide range of environmental factors; and the same sensitive dependence also applies to the time taken for colonization on fresh rock surfaces. These problems cast doubt on many absolute dating studies and critics have suggested that, at best, the technique should only be used for relative dating. This paper provides guidance on identification procedures and suggests alternative dating methods based on lichen size-frequency distributions and cross-dating with other lichen species, thus avoiding reliance on a single species or support from other methods. With appropriate development, it is hoped that these approaches can provide a way forward that allows the technique to contribute more reliably to the dating of rock surfaces in regions where there are few other dating options.Keywords
This publication has 77 references indexed in Scilit:
- Lichenometry as Applied to Moraines in Alaska, U.S.A., and Kamchatka, RussiaArctic, Antarctic, and Alpine Research, 2003
- Air pressure and cosmogenic isotope productionJournal of Geophysical Research, 2000
- A new approach to lichenometry: dating single-age and diachronous surfacesThe Holocene, 1994
- Experiments on Lichen Growth II. Effects of a Seasonal Snow CoverArctic and Alpine Research, 1991
- Lichen Mortality Due to Late-Lying Snow: Results of a Transplant StudyArctic and Alpine Research, 1990
- Rhizocarpon Ram. em. Th. Fr. Subgen. Rhizocarpon in EuropeArctic and Alpine Research, 1988
- Lichenometric Chronology and Archaeological Features on Raised Beaches: Preliminary Results from the Swedish North Bothnian Coastal RegionArctic and Alpine Research, 1986
- Growth analysis of circular lichen thalliJournal of Theoretical Biology, 1979
- The effect of environment on assemblages of lichens growing on rock surfacesNew Zealand Journal of Botany, 1972
- Lichen succession on recently deposited rock surfacesNew Zealand Journal of Botany, 1970