Temporal dynamics of insect herbivory in understory trees across temperate and tropical forests
Open Access
Abstract
Insect herbivory shapes forest ecosystems by affecting plant growth, nutrient cycling, and regeneration. It is commonly believed that tropical forest understories face greater insect herbivory pressure than their temperate counterparts. Yet, the magnitude of this tropical–temperate contrast remains debated. To address this gap, we examined how insect herbivory accumulates over time on understory woody plants across six temperate and tropical forests in Germany, Japan, China, Papua New Guinea, and Australia. We initiated the sampling during the early growing season in temperate forests and the onset of the wet season in tropical forests, and followed it by resampling. We quantified both standing herbivory and its temporal accumulation over 1‐month and 4‐month intervals on 44 understory tree species. Early in the growing season, standing herbivory was higher at low‐latitude, aseasonal tropical sites than at higher‐latitude temperate sites. However, herbivory accumulated more rapidly in temperate forests during the first month, consistent with intense feeding during spring leaf flush. As a result, initial tropical–temperate differences diminished rapidly, with standing herbivory converging within 1 month and remaining similar after 4 months. In tropical forests, herbivory accumulation was more stable through time, likely reflecting continuous leaf production and sustained herbivore activity. In summary, insect herbivory was primarily shaped by contrasting temporal dynamics of accumulation across forest types. Herbivory varied with latitude early in the season, accumulated rapidly in temperate forests, and converged across sites after 4 months, resulting in no consistent difference between tropical and temperate understories later in the season. These results demonstrate that herbivory accumulation over time is a key driver of observed patterns, which differ during the annual cycle. These findings highlight the importance of multi‐temporal assessments of insect herbivory and caution against inferring broad‐scale herbivory patterns from single time‐point surveys.Keywords
Funding Information
- Grantová Agentura České Republiky (22‐17593M)
- H2020 European Research Council (805189)
This publication has 68 references indexed in Scilit:
- Substantial Insect Herbivory in a South African Savanna‐Forest Mosaic: A Neglected TopicEcology and Evolution, 2024
- Effects of phylogeny, traits, and seasonality on invertebrate herbivory damage in a meadow communityActa Oecologica, 2022
- How much leaf area do insects eat? A data set of insect herbivory sampled globally with a standardized protocolEcology, 2021
- Leaf synchrony and insect herbivory among tropical tree habitat specialistsPlant Ecology, 2014
- Different mechanisms explain feeding type-specific patterns of latitudinal variation in herbivore damage among diverse feeding types of herbivorous insectsBasic and Applied Ecology, 2013
- Rainfall seasonality and pest pressure as determinants of tropical tree species' distributionsEcology and Evolution, 2012
- ggplot2WIREs Computational Statistics, 2011
- Do tropical forest leaves suffer more insect herbivory? A comparison of tropical versus temperate herbivory, estimated from leaf litterEcological Research, 2009
- Insect Herbivores, Nutrient Cycling and Plant Productivity2008
- Compatible Management of Understory Forest Resources and Timber2003