Is Greenberg's "Macro-Carib" viable?
Open Access
- 1 August 2007
- journal article
- Published by FapUNIFESP (SciELO) in Boletim do Museu Paraense Emílio Goeldi. Ciências Humanas
- Vol. 2 (2) , 19-72
Abstract
In his landmark work Language in the Americas, Greenberg (1987) proposed that Macro-Carib was one of the major low-level stocks of South America, which together with Macro-Panoan and Macro-Ge-Bororo were claimed to comprise the putative Ge-Pano-Carib Phylum. His Macro-Carib includes the isolates Andoke and Kukura, and the Witotoan, Peba-Yaguan, and Cariban families. Greenberg's primary evidence came from person-marking paradigms in individual languages, plus scattered words from individual languages collected into 79 Macro-Carib 'etymologies' and another 64 Amerind 'etymologies'. The goal of this paper is to re-evaluate Greenberg's Macro-Carib claim in the light of the much more extensive and reliable language data that has become available largely since 1987. Based on full person-marking paradigms for Proto-Cariban, Yagua, Bora and Andoke, we conclude that Greenberg's morphological claims are unfounded. For our lexical comparison, we created lexical lists for Proto-Cariban, Proto-Witotoan, Yagua and Andoke, for both Greenberg's 143 putative etymologies and for the Swadesh 100 list. From both lists, a total of 23 potential cognates were found, but no consonantal correspondences were repeated even once. We conclude that our greatly expanded and improved database does not provide sufficient evidence to convince the skeptic that the Macro-Carib hypothesis is viableKeywords
This publication has 14 references indexed in Scilit:
- Source of the Yagua Nominal Classification SystemInternational Journal of American Linguistics, 2007
- The Southern Cariban Languages and the Cariban FamilyInternational Journal of American Linguistics, 2005
- The Amazonian languages. Ed. by R. M. W. Dixon and Alexandra Aikhenvald. (Cambridge language surveys.) Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1999. Pp. xxviii, 446.Language, 2001
- A Critique of Muskogean, "Gulf," and Yukian Material in "Language in the Americas"International Journal of American Linguistics, 1992
- A Comment on the Yurok and Kalapuya Data in Greenberg's Language in the AmericasInternational Journal of American Linguistics, 1992
- On Calculating the Factor of Chance in Language ComparisonTransactions of the American Philosophical Society, 1992
- Classification of American Indian Languages: A Reply to CampbellLanguage, 1989
- Noun classification in the Western AmazonLanguage Sciences, 1987
- Pronouns in Yagua DiscourseInternational Journal of American Linguistics, 1987
- Proto Hianacoto: Guaque-Carijona-Hianacoto UmauaInternational Journal of American Linguistics, 1973