Do Mosquito Coils Prevent Malaria? A Systematic Review of Trials
Authors:
- Ashley M. CroftACAshley M. Croft
Open Access
- 10 March 2006
- journal article
- review article
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Journal of Travel Medicine
- Vol. 11 (2) , 92-96
Abstract
Official guidelines commonly advise travelers to burn mosquito coils as one means of preventing malaria. The objective of this study was to discover if insecticide-containing mosquito coils (1) prevent mosquito bites and therefore malaria acquisition, and (2) are safe in terms of their adverse effects on human users. We sought published and unpublished controlled trials in this area, by (1) contacting experts, (2) searching the Cochrane Library, (3) interrogating bibliographic databases, (4) Internet search, (5) citation scanning, (6) scanning conference proceedings, and (7) writing to manufacturers. Fifteen controlled trials of insecticide-containing mosquito coils met our predefined inclusion criteria. We found no controlled trials measuring the incidence of clinical malaria as an outcome. Studies tested the efficacy of coils in achieving mosquito bite reduction (reported in 14 studies), mosquito repellence (seven), deterrence (five), “knockdown” effect (five), and percentage mosquito mortality (seven). Of the 38 separate outcome measures reported, antimosquito efficacy was reported as positive for >95%. One trial reported no antimosquito effect at all, for one outcome only. Some insecticide classes and strengths were associated with better antimosquito outcomes than others. One trial identified possible adverse effects (irritation of the eyes and nose) in human users of this technology. There is no evidence that burning insecticide-containing mosquito coils prevents malaria acquisition. A randomized field trial should be conducted, with malaria incidence as a primary outcome. There is consistent evidence that burning coils inhibits nuisance biting by various mosquito species. The potential harmful effects of coil smoke on human users should be investigated.Keywords
This publication has 10 references indexed in Scilit:
- Malaria during a multinational military deployment: the comparative experience of the Italian, British and Australian Armed Forces in East TimorTransactions of the Royal Society of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene, 2002
- Systematic Reviews in Health Care2001
- Malaria on the Move: Human Population Movement and Malaria TransmissionEmerging Infectious Diseases, 2000
- Self-protection from malaria vectors in Pakistan: an evaluation of popular existing methods and appropriate new techniques in Afghan refugee communitiesPathogens and Global Health, 1996
- Systematic Reviews: Rationale for systematic reviewsBMJ, 1994
- Ineffectiveness of mosquito coils in Kinshasa, ZaireTransactions of the Royal Society of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene, 1989
- The effectiveness of mosquito coils containing esbiothrin under laboratory and field conditionsPathogens and Global Health, 1987
- The coil works (against mosquitoes in Papua New Guinea)Transactions of the Royal Society of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene, 1984
- The activity of some pyrethroids, DDT and lindane in smoke from coils for biting inhibition, knockdown and kill of mosquitoes (Diptera, Culicidae)Bulletin of Entomological Research, 1975
- The effects of smoke from mosquito coils on Anopheles gambiae Giles and Mansonia uniformis (Theo.) in verandah-trap huts at Magugu, TanzaniaBulletin of Entomological Research, 1971