Categorical and Dimensional Diagnoses of Dyslexia: Are They Compatible?
Authors:
Open Access
- 28 August 2020
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Frontiers Media SA in Frontiers in Psychology
- Vol. 11
Abstract
Dyslexia is often assessed using categorical diagnoses, and subtypes of dyslexia are also recognized in a categorical fashion. Children may meet the criteria for dyslexia, and they may more specifically meet the criteria for a subtype of it, and thus get a diagnosis. This approach to diagnosis clashes with the actual distribution of reading performance in children (which is normal and continuous), and it has received criticism. This article offers a conceptual framework for conciliating these two positions. In short, the proposal is to use a set of multicomponent continuous assessments of reading, rather than thresholds. The proposal is explained using original data obtained from a sample of 30 children (age 7 to 11), tested in the United Kingdom. Using an assessment based on categorical-thresholds, only five children in our sample qualify for extra assistance, and only one may get a diagnosis of dyslexia, while with the mixed system proposed, a few additional children in the gray area would receive attention. This approach would not discard previous categorical approaches such as those distinguishing between surface and phonological dyslexia, but it would rather see these subtypes of dyslexia as the instance of a lower score on the continuum obtained on a single component of the multicomponent assessment.Keywords
This publication has 32 references indexed in Scilit:
- The Submerged Dyslexia Iceberg: How Many School Children Are Not Diagnosed? Results from an Italian StudyPLOS ONE, 2012
- Dyslexia in Chinese language: An overview of research and practiceAustralian Journal of Learning Difficulties, 2010
- Dyslexia: The evolution of a scientific conceptJournal of the International Neuropsychological Society, 2009
- Phonological dyslexia and dysgraphia: Cognitive mechanisms and neural substratesCortex, 2009
- Does Dyslexia Exist?Journal of Philosophy of Education, 2008
- A Developmental fMRI Study of Reading and Repetition Reveals Changes in Phonological and Visual Mechanisms Over AgeCerebral Cortex, 2008
- It does matter: the importance of making the diagnosis of a genetic syndromeCurrent Opinion in Pediatrics, 2006
- Dyslexia as a Phonological Deficit: Evidence and ImplicationsChild and Adolescent Mental Health, 1998
- The children's test of nonword repetition: A test of phonological working memoryMemory, 1994
- Working Memory and Reading: A Life-span PerspectiveInternational Journal of Behavioral Development, 1994