Trolleyology and the Dengue Vaccine Dilemma
Author:
Open Access
- 26 July 2018
- journal article
- editorial
- Published by Massachusetts Medical Society in New England Journal of Medicine
- Vol. 379 (4) , 305-307
Abstract
“Trolleyology” refers to a series of moral dilemmas that reveal the tensions between utilitarianism — the idea that a behavior is moral if its consequences maximize public good — and our individual intuitions about right and wrong.1 In a classic scenario, an observer is standing by a railway track where he spots a runaway trolley barreling toward five people who will soon be killed. He’s standing by a switch that, if pulled, would divert the trolley away from the five but cause it to kill one person in its new path. In a related scenario, the observer is on a footbridge when he spots the trolley, and he’s standing by a very large man. If he pushes the man off the bridge, the body will stop the trolley; the five people would be saved, but the man would die. What should the observer do? Most people believe he should pull the switch in the first scenario but shouldn’t push the man in the second. Philosophers, psychologists, and even neuroscientists, have spent the past several decades debating why. One common explanation, familiar to most people who practice medicine, distinguishes between the immorality of intentional harms and the acceptability of merely “foreseen” ones. We wouldn’t, for instance, prematurely end the life of a man who’s had a disabling stroke, even though his organs could be used to save five other patients’ lives.Keywords
This publication has 4 references indexed in Scilit:
- Dengue vaccine: WHO position paper, July 2016 – recommendationsVaccine, 2017
- The social dilemma of autonomous vehiclesScience, 2016
- Would You Kill the Fat Man?2013
- Reluctance to vaccinate: Omission bias and ambiguityJournal of Behavioral Decision Making, 1990