Limits of Couinaud's Liver Segment Classification: A Quantitative Computer-Based Three-Dimensional Analysis
Authors:
- Lars FischerLFLars Fischer
- Carlos CardenasCCCarlos Cardenas
- Matthias ThornMTMatthias Thorn
- Axel BennerABAxel Benner
- Lars GrenacherLGLars Grenacher
- Markus VetterMVMarkus Vetter
- Thomas LehnertTLThomas Lehnert
- Ernst KlarEKErnst Klar
- Hans-Peter MeinzerHMHans-Peter Meinzer
- Wolfram LamadéWLWolfram Lamadé
- 1 November 2002
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wolters Kluwer Health in Journal of Computer Assisted Tomography
- Vol. 26 (6) , 962-967
Abstract
Traditionally, liver surgery relies on Couinaud's liver segment classification. As the position and shape of these segments are variable and their borders are hidden within the homogeneous liver mass, the accuracy of segment identification methods needs computer-aided reevaluation. The segmental liver anatomy of 23 patients receiving diagnostic helical CT scans because of suspected intrahepatic lesion was analyzed with the aid of a computer-based operation-planning system. We compared the standard Couinaud classification, which depends particularly on the main stems of portal and hepatic veins, with a method that calculates the segment borders by analyzing the complete portal venous tree. Volume, shape, and position of the liver segments found by each method were compared. With reference to the portal vein-based method, segmental volumes were overestimated by the classic Couinaud method by up to 24% and underestimated to 13%. Volumes of Couinaud segments 4a, 7, and 8 were generally larger compared with those obtained by the portal vein-based method, whereas segments 3 and 6 were smaller. Gross variations were found in segments 5, 7, and 8. When shape and position were considered, poor correlation was found for five segments (median kappa = 0.35-0.45). Only segments 2, 7, and 8 had kappa values clearly above 0.45 in the majority of cases. The plane that divides the two hemilivers along the middle hepatic vein and the border between the left sector (segments 2 and 3) and the medial sector (4a and 4b) were found in both methods with very good conformity (kappa > 0.75). Couinaud's method of dividing the liver into eight autonomous liver segments has to be accepted as a good approximation. Nevertheless, the volume, position, and shape of these segments and their segmental borders show significant variability.Keywords
This publication has 10 references indexed in Scilit:
- The Impact of 3-Dimensional Reconstructions on Operation Planning in Liver SurgeryArchives of Surgery, 2000
- Individuelle Planung leberchirurgischer Eingriffe an einem virtuellen Modell der Leber und ihrer LeitstrukturenDer Radiologe, 2000
- Virtuelle Operationsplanung in der LeberchirurgieDer Chirurg, 1999
- Virtual planning of liver resections: image processing, visualization and volumetric evaluationInternational Journal of Medical Informatics, 1999
- Virtual Reality Applied to Hepatic Surgery Simulation: The Next RevolutionAnnals of Surgery, 1998
- Segmental anatomy of the liver: poor correlation with CT.Radiology, 1998
- Three-Dimensional Helical CT of Intrahepatic Venous Structures: Comparison of Three Rendering TechniquesJournal of Computer Assisted Tomography, 1996
- 7 3-D reconstruction of hepatic neoplasms: a preoperative planning procedureBailliere's Clinical Gastroenterology, 1995
- Correspondence analysis in medical researchStatistical Methods in Medical Research, 1992
- Intrahepatic Branching Patterns of Portal VeinGastroenterology, 1977