The Effect of Bilateral Laminotomy Versus Laminectomy on the Motion and Stiffness of the Human Lumbar Spine
Authors:
- Michael J. LeeMLMichael J. Lee
- Richard J. BransfordRBRichard J. Bransford
- Carlo BellabarbaCBCarlo Bellabarba
- Jens R. ChapmanJCJens R. Chapman
- Amy M. CohenACAmy M. Cohen
- Richard M. HarringtonRHRichard M. Harrington
- Randal P. ChingRCRandal P. Ching
- 1 September 2010
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wolters Kluwer Health in Spine
- Vol. 35 (19) , 1789-1793
Abstract
A cadaveric simulation model of the lumbar spine was used to study the intervertebral motion characteristics of the lumbar spine after bilateral laminotomy and facet-sparing laminectomy. To assess differences in motion patterns and lumbar spine stiffness after bilateral laminotomy versus laminectomy. Spondylolisthesis after facet-sparing laminectomy has been reported with a frequency of 8% to 31%. Bilateral laminotomies have been shown to be effective in decompressing the spine, without resection of the posterior osteo-ligamentous complex. We hypothesize that bilateral laminotomies induce significantly less iatrogenic hypermobility and less stiffness reduction than a traditional facet-sparing laminectomy in the lumbar spine. Six fresh frozen human cadaveric lumbar spines (L1–L5) were mounted into a spine motion simulator for testing. With physiologic follower preload, flexion/extension, lateral bending, and axial rotation moments were applied to the lumbar spine in 3 trials: (1) Intact lumbar spine—no surgery, (2) Lumbar spine after bilateral lumbar laminotomies at L2–L5, (3) Lumbar spine after full laminectomies at L2–L5. The lumbar spine kinematics were measured using a Vicon motion tracking system. Total and segmental range of motion and spine stiffness were recorded. In flexion/extension, bilateral laminotomies resulted in an average increase in L2–L5 range of flexion/extension motion of 14.3%, whereas a full laminectomy resulted in an increase of 32.0% (P < 0.05). Analysis per level demonstrated roughly twofold increase in motion with laminectomy compared with bilateral laminotomies (P < 0.05, at every treated level). Stiffness was decreased by an average of 11.8% after the 3-level-laminotomies and by 27.2% (P < 0.05) after the 3-level-laminectomy. These data demonstrate that bilateral laminotomies induce significantly less hypermobility and less stiffness reduction compared with a full laminectomy. The preservation of the central posterior osteo-ligamentous structures may provide a stabilizing effect in preventing postdecompression spondylolisthesis.Keywords
This publication has 19 references indexed in Scilit:
- Biomechanical comparison of lumbar spine instability between laminectomy and bilateral laminotomy for spinal stenosis syndrome – an experimental study in porcine modelBMC Musculoskeletal Disorders, 2008
- Long-term Outcomes of Two Different Decompressive Techniques for Lumbar Spinal StenosisSpine, 2008
- Midterm outcome after unilateral approach for bilateral decompression of lumbar spinal stenosis: 5-year prospective studyEuropean Spine Journal, 2007
- Unilateral multilevel interlaminar fenestration instead of laminectomy or hemilaminectomy: an alternative surgical approach to intraspinal space-occupying lesionsJournal of Neurosurgery: Spine, 2007
- Clinical outcomes and radiological instability following decompressive lumbar laminectomy for degenerative spinal stenosis: a comparison of patients undergoing concomitant arthrodesis versus decompression aloneJournal of Neurosurgery, 1996
- The surgical treatment of central lumbar stenosis. Multiple laminotomy compared with total laminectomyThe Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery. British volume, 1993
- Biomechanical Evaluation of Lumbar Spinal Stability After Graded FacetectomiesSpine, 1990
- Preoperative and Postoperative Instability in Lumbar Spinal StenosisSpine, 1989
- The Injudicious LaminectomySpine, 1986
- Lumbar Spinal Instability (Olisthesis) After Extensive Posterior Spinal DecompressionSpine, 1983