Motivation to Adopt Evaluation Practice as a Determinant of Evaluation Use
Open Access
- 10 December 2024
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in American Journal of Evaluation
- Vol. 46 (1) , 22-38
Abstract
The literature contains several models that link types of evaluation use with organizational factors. However, until now, none of them have been thoroughly verified. This study aims to empirically verify the hypotheses proposed by Steven Højlund, who suggests that the type of evaluation use in organizations is determined by the adoption mode of evaluation practice (coercive, mimetic, normative, or voluntary). Qualitative comparative analysis was conducted on 23 cases from departments of Polish municipal administration, revealing the necessary conditions for most types of evaluation use. Instrumental use resulted from voluntary adoption, symbolic use from coercive adoption, and normative adoption—or the absence of coercive factors—led to legitimizing use. The situation was least clear for conceptual use, where we identified three possible combinations of necessary conditions. Although we found some significant relationships between adoption modes and types of evaluation use, the overall explanatory potential of Højlund's model appears to be quite limited.Keywords
Funding Information
- Narodowe Centrum Nauki (2019/33/B/HS5/01336)
This publication has 55 references indexed in Scilit:
- Does evaluation quality matter? Quantitative analysis of the use of evaluation findings in the field of cohesion policy in PolandEvaluation and Program Planning, 2022
- Qualitative Comparative Analysis Using R2021
- Explaining use and non-use of policy evaluations in a mature evaluation settingHumanities and Social Sciences Communications, 2020
- A review of integrated QCA and statistical analysesQuality & Quantity, 2016
- Set-Theoretic Methods for the Social Sciences2012
- The New Public Management and Evaluation2007
- Increasing evaluation capacity within community-based HIV prevention programsEvaluation and Program Planning, 2002
- Unbundling evaluation useStudies in Educational Evaluation, 2002
- Reconceptualizing evaluation use: An integrated theory of influenceNew Directions for Evaluation, 2000
- The utilization of needs assessment resultsEvaluation and Program Planning, 1993