Abstract
The average list size per general practitioner in England was 1866 in 1998.4 The crude mortality in Britain is currently 1.1% a year. The table shows the number of deaths expected according to practice size, together with the minimum number of deaths for which the lower limit of a 99% confidence interval from the Poisson distribution would exclude the national rate. As there are some 9000 practices in England, the use of 99% confidence intervals would, by definition, necessitate the intense investigation of the 0.5% (approximately 45) practices annually above this limit. In larger practices 30-40 excess deaths a year would not be detected as statistically exceptional. Shipman's practice list of 3600 would allow an excess of 18 deaths a year above the average to pass as unremarkable, which is more than the 15 murders over three years he is currently convicted of (a murder rate of five per year) and also more than the high estimate of 175 murders over more than a decade, although repetitively elevated mortality, even if below the threshold, could, with extra effort, receive additional monitoring. Even if such monitoring were restricted to deaths that occurred outside hospital, random variation would mask considerable illegitimate mortality.
Keywords

This publication has 1 reference indexed in Scilit: