Abstract
The premise of this analysis is that normative universality in human rights, including the rights of the child, should neither be taken for granted nor achieved through the ‘universalization’ of the norms and institutions of dominant cultures, whether at the local, regional or international levels. In relation to the definition and implementation of the best interests of the child principle, the paper emphasizes the need to maximize opportunities for contesting the nature and rationale of action regarding children from as many different perspectives as possible. This should include rigorous analysis to see who is taking the action in question, on what basis and for whose benefit, how does it affect children at large or groups thereof, and so forth. Particular attention should be given to understanding the nature, context and dynamics of power relations between and among the various actors and subjects of the action in question, and possibilities of altering or adjusting those power relations. Thus, the essential feature in developing specific strategies for substantive normative consensus is the need to enable alternative perceptions and interpretations of cultural norms and institutions to emerge and compete with dominant ones. Such procedural universality, the paper concludes, is both readily achievable and conducive to the realization of genuine normative consensus on the definition and implementation of principles such as the best interests of the child.