SOCIOLOGICAL CULTURAL STUDIES: THE QUESTION OF EXPLANATION
Author:
- Gregor McLennanGMGregor McLennan
- 1 September 2002
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Cultural Studies
- Vol. 16 (5) , 631-649
Abstract
This article focuses on the relationship between sociology and cultural studies, arguing that sociological cultural studies represent an important transdisciplinary platform. The discussion highlights the work of a number of under-valued authors, positing, in a provisional way, that where sociology remains drawn to an ethos of ‘explanatory’ causal reasoning, cultural studies typically occupies a register of evocative and engaged social ‘description’. Despite the heuristic value of this schema, which casts light on more recent theoretical initiatives (such as‘the method of articulation’) as well as ‘canonical’ figures, the distinction between explanation and description is shown to be ultimately difficult to sustain. This reinforces the overall theme of the paper that whilst there are sometimes very different emphases at work within sociology and cultural studies, they need to be seen as complementary discourses operating within the same intellectual field.Keywords
This publication has 10 references indexed in Scilit:
- Explaining Explanation2003
- Sociology's ComplexitySociology, 2003
- Quandaries in meta-theory: against pluralismEconomy and Society, 2002
- Cultures of Inquiry1999
- Sociology and cultural studies: rhetorics of disciplinary identityHistory of the Human Sciences, 1998
- Cultural Studies in Question1997
- Passionate Sociology1996
- The craft of large-scale theory: W. G. Runciman and the neo- traditionalist revival in sociological theoryJournal of Sociology, 1995
- The End of Sociological Theory: The Postmodern HopeSociological Theory, 1991
- Rhetoric in Sociology1984