Abstract
In 1998, the Recognition of Customary Marriages Act 120 of 1998 was passed by Parliament. In 2001, the South African Law Commission published a Discussion Paper on the validity of Muslim marriages. In both customary and religious law, the State is faced with the choice of either creating a single system of marriage law for all religious and cultural groups, or maintaining separate systems to cater for different sectors of the population. In making this choice, issues of gender equality and the recognition of religious and cultural rights invariably surface. This article examines issues relating to the recognition of religious and cultural systems of family law by way of an analysis of two cases that represent the two most frequently suggested ‘solutions’, namely unification of family law and pluralism. Using elements of feminist standpoint analysis and postmodernism, the construction of the ideal legal subject established in the cases, as well as its implications for women, is interrogated. The article then makes some observations about the nature of South African family law after the adoption of the Constitution. This discussion is also relevant to the way in which a new South African society will deal with challenges by marginalised cultures and social practices to western middle class cultural hegemony.

This publication has 3 references indexed in Scilit: