Addressing the risks of dual use research: who is responsible?
Authors:
Open Access
- 31 July 2024
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Research Ethics
- Vol. 21 (2) , 267-285
Abstract
This article addresses the question of how the responsibilities for addressing the risks of dual use research ought to be divided. We begin by presenting the maximalist claim that proposes that since scientists are well placed to judge the potential for misuse of their studies, they alone are responsible for addressing these risks. Before assessing this position, we consider a claim that rejects the maximalist position, namely that scientists need not consider the possibility that their studies might be misused because the goods of science are so important, they should not spend time on anything but generating valuable knowledge. This claim, we argue, fails, as these goods do not always outweigh the risks of misuse. Given this conclusion we turn to assess two versions of the maximalist claim. The first suggests that when a possibility of misuse arises, scientists ought to adopt the precautionary principle (PP) to discharge their moral responsibilities. We argue that PP is problematic as it does not give much guidance on what scientists should do. An alternative to meeting scientists’ moral responsibilities is through applying a risk-benefit analysis; however, due to epistemic biases and limitations, scientists are prone to make mistakes in their analysis. We thus suggest an alternative approach, in which responsibilities are divided between scientists and agents that can conduct an analysis that is more likely to generate unbiased and comprehensive conclusions on how the risks of dual use research, should be addressed.Keywords
This publication has 21 references indexed in Scilit:
- The trinity of good research: Distinguishing between research integrity, ethics, and governanceAccountability in Research, 2023
- Reconciling Regulation with Scientific Autonomy in Dual-Use ResearchThe Journal of Medicine and Philosophy: A Forum for Bioethics and Philosophy of Medicine, 2022
- A Framework for Reviewing Dual Use Research2021
- The Silver Lining in Gain-of-Function Experiments with Pathogens of Pandemic Potential2018
- The dual-use problem, scientific isolationism and the division of moral labourMonash Bioethics Review, 2014
- H5N1 Avian Flu Research and the Ethics of KnowledgeHastings Center Report, 2013
- Experimental adaptation of an influenza H5 HA confers respiratory droplet transmission to a reassortant H5 HA/H1N1 virus in ferretsNature, 2012
- A PRECAUTIONARY PRINCIPLE FOR DUAL USE RESEARCH IN THE LIFE SCIENCESBioethics, 2010
- In Defence of Bad Science and Irrational Policies: an Alternative Account of the Precautionary PrincipleEthical Theory and Moral Practice, 2009
- TAKING DUE CARE: MORAL OBLIGATIONS IN DUAL USE RESEARCHBioethics, 2008