Temporary projects, durable outcomes: Urban development through failed Olympic bids?
- 12 May 2015
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Urban Studies
- Vol. 53 (9) , 1885-1901
Abstract
However it may be defined, urban ‘development’ typically implies the production of durable legacies. Yet these legacies are often planned through contingent, temporary projects. The role of temporary projects in implementing urban development is often interpreted in linear fashion: projects are viewed as isolated events which incrementally work toward already-existing development agendas. I argue instead that temporary projects play a recursive role in development planning: interpreted as a series of interlinked projects, they not only support but also redefine agendas for durable development. I focus on one type of temporary project: (failed) bids to host the Olympics, which I assess through a comparative 20-year sample of bids and through case studies of failed bids in Doha (Qatar) and New York (USA). I show that event-led development planning leverages project contingency and policy failure to construct long-term development agendas, as cities bid multiple times and recycle plans across projects. The paper contributes to debates over the long-term impacts of speculation and experimentation in urban governance, by assessing the role of contingency in urban politics. Temporariness is an asset in urban politics which can be used to mitigate risk in speculative development planning: since Olympic bids often fail to secure hosting rights, references to the possibility of failure can insulate project planners from critique.Keywords
This publication has 55 references indexed in Scilit:
- The neoliberalisation of strategic spatial planningPlanning Theory, 2013
- Contextualizing Olympic LegaciesUrban Geography, 2011
- Toronto's Olympic Aspirations: A Bid for the Waterfront1Urban Geography, 2011
- Contracts and Learning in Complex Urban ProjectsInternational Journal of Urban and Regional Research, 2011
- International Urban Festivals as a Catalyst for Governance Capacity BuildingEnvironment and Planning C: Government and Policy, 2010
- Resisting Urban Spectacle: The 1984 Louisiana World Exposition and the Contradictions of Mega EventsUrban Studies, 2010
- The urban politics of roll‐with‐it neoliberalizationCity, 2009
- Neoliberalism as a mobile technologyTransactions of the Institute of British Geographers, 2007
- Neoliberalizing SpaceAntipode, 2002
- Olympic Games: catalyst of urban changeLeisure Studies, 1998