Balancing Legalism and Pragmatism: A Qualitative Content Analysis of Human Rights Language in Peace Agreements
Open Access
- 5 September 2023
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Journal of Human Rights Practice
- Vol. 16 (1) , 325-341
Abstract
In recent decades, the role of human rights in peacebuilding has been the object of scholarly and practitioner debate. Some commentators criticize human rights for being inflexibly legalist and for lacking pragmatism regarding the domestic implementation of international law. Other scholars support the inclusion of human rights provisions in peace agreements, as central to sustainable peace. Which account—the legalist or the pragmatist—is indeed more accurate in the context of the language of peace agreements? This research draws on the scholarship on peacebuilding and human rights to offer a qualitative content analysis of human rights provisions in 357 peace agreements signed from 1990 to 2020. The analysis finds that, in peace agreements, some human rights provisions can serve a wider range of peace-related purposes that go far beyond a legalist purpose while still advancing the importance of alignment with international law. The findings are important, suggesting that our quest for the causes of human rights implementation failures might have to move past a critique of the language of human rights and look elsewhere for factors explaining non-compliance with international human rights.Keywords
This publication has 29 references indexed in Scilit:
- Introduction2015
- Just How Liberal Is the Liberal Peace?International Peacekeeping, 2014
- Civil Society and Peace Negotiations: Beyond the Inclusion–Exclusion DichotomyNegotiation Journal, 2014
- The myth of liberal peace-buildingConflict, Security & Development, 2013
- Anchoring the Peace: Civil Society Actors in Peace Accords and Durable PeaceInternational Interactions, 2012
- Law From Below: Women's Human Rights and Social Movements in New York CityLaw & Society Review, 2010
- ‘Bringing coals to Newcastle’? Human rights, civil rights and social movements in New York CityGlobal Networks, 2009
- An Unfinished Enterprise: Visions, Reflections, and an InvitationJournal of Human Rights Practice, 2009
- “The Most We Can Hope For...”: Human Rights and the Politics of FatalismSouth Atlantic Quarterly, 2004
- Trials and Errors: Principle and Pragmatism in Strategies of International JusticeInternational Security, 2004