Primordialism for Scholars Who Ought to Know Better: Anthony D. Smith’s Critique of Modernization Theory
- 25 March 2020
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Nationalities Papers
- Vol. 48 (5) , 826-842
Abstract
A theory of nationalism should explain the evidence provided by the historical record, but also provide unexpected insight. The modernist theory of nationalism, espoused among others by Benedict Anderson and Eric Hobsbawm, provides a surprising chronology of nationalism’s modernity. The modernization theory of nationalism has attracted extensive criticism from Anthony Smith, who proposed instead a theory he called “ethnosymbolism.” This article considers Smith’s critique of Anderson and then his critique of Hobsbawm, finding that Smith’s objections to modernist theorists rest on mischaracterizations, fallacies, and contradictions. Smith’s approach caters to the primordialism rampant in public opinion, providing scholarly respectability to popular misconceptions. Scholars of nationalism should look instead to Rogers Brubaker for guidance.Keywords
This publication has 38 references indexed in Scilit:
- School History Atlases as Instruments of Nation-State Making and MaintenanceJournal of Educational Media, Memory, and Society, 2010
- Stigmatized by History or by Historians? The Peoples of Russia in School History TextbooksHistory & Memory, 2009
- Re-Writing the History of Romania after the Fall of CommunismHistory Compass, 2005
- Nationalism and Modernism: A Critical Survey of Recent Theories of Nations and NationalismContemporary Sociology: A Journal of Reviews, 2000
- The terms of the debate: Untangling language about ethnicity and ethnic movementsEthnic and Racial Studies, 1997
- Nations and Nationalism in a Global EraThe British Journal of Sociology, 1996
- National IdentityForeign Affairs, 1993
- The Ethnic Origins of NationsThe British Journal of Sociology, 1988
- Social Preconditions of National Revival in Europe: A Comparative Analysis of the Social Composition of Patriotic Groups among the Smaller European NationsThe American Historical Review, 1986
- Theories of NationalismThe American Historical Review, 1973