International theory in a post-paradigmatic era: From substantive wagers to scientific ontologies
Authors:
- 5 September 2013
- journal article
- Published by SAGE Publications in European Journal of International Relations
- Vol. 19 (3) , 543-565
Abstract
Concerns about the end of International Relations theory pivot around at least three different issues: the fading of the ‘paradigm wars’ associated with the 1990s and early 2000s; the general lack of any sort of ‘great debate’ sufficient to occupy the attention of large portions of the field; and claims about the vibrancy of middle-range theorizing. None of these are terribly helpful when it comes to assessing the health of International Relations theory. We argue that international theory involves scientific ontologies of world politics: topographies of entities, processes, mechanisms, and how they relate to one another. Understood this way, the state of International Relations theory looks strong: there is arguably more out there than ever before. Ironically, this cornucopia helps explain concerns regarding the end of International Relations theory. In the absence of a ‘great debate,’ let alone ways of organizing contemporary International Relations theory, this diversity descends into cacophony. We submit that three major clusters of international theory are emerging: choice-theoretic, experience-near, and social-relational. These clusters map onto two major axes of contention: (1) the degree that actors should be treated as autonomous from their environment; and (2) the importance of thickly contextual analysis. These disputes are both field-wide and high-stakes, even if we do not always recognize them as such.Keywords
This publication has 61 references indexed in Scilit:
- Everyday CounterinsurgencyInternational Political Sociology, 2011
- The Mundane MattersInternational Political Sociology, 2011
- The International as an Everyday PracticeInternational Political Sociology, 2011
- Pierre Bourdieu and International Relations: Power of Practices, Practices of PowerInternational Political Sociology, 2011
- Network Analysis for International RelationsInternational Organization, 2009
- Brokering change: networks and entrepreneurs in international politicsInternational Theory, 2009
- What's at Stake in the American Empire DebateAmerican Political Science Review, 2007
- Paradigm Lost? Reassessing Theory of International PoliticsEuropean Journal of International Relations, 2005
- Constitution, Choice and Change: Problems with the `Logic of Appropriateness' and its Use in Constructivist TheoryEuropean Journal of International Relations, 2002
- Relations Before States:European Journal of International Relations, 1999