Doctrinal Legal Science: A Science of Its Own?
Open Access
- 1 August 2024
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Canadian Journal of Law & Jurisprudence
- Vol. 37 (2) , 343-367
Abstract
Doctrinal legal scholarship faces persistent challenges from empirical approaches, but such criticism rarely seeks to encounter doctrine on its own terms. In this article, we seek to excavate the theoretical and methodological basis of doctrinal legal scholarship by situating the discipline in a hermeneutic continuum between theory and practice, or law’s engagement with the social world. We first unfold this dynamic as an exercise in methodological interpretivism and ontological hermeneutics and then turn to explicate our analysis with examples drawn from tort law and international criminal law. We ultimately argue that law can never be strictly circumscribed as an empirical object because law cannot be disassociated from an agent’s reasons, which are continuously bound up in a hermeneutic circle, and which the scholar must enter into to achieve legal understanding. Unavoidably, therefore, doctrinal legal scholarship becomes part of the very object it is investigating.Keywords
All Related Versions
This publication has 5 references indexed in Scilit:
- Three Essays on Torts2021
- The Citation Practices of the High Court of Australia, 1905–2015Federal Law Review, 2019
- Law as a Parasitic DisciplineJournal of Law and Society, 1998
- LEGAL SCHOLARSHIP IN AUSTRALIAThe Modern Law Review, 1987
- Knowledge and Human InterestsThe British Journal of Sociology, 1972