Abstract
Upper echelons theory posits that organisational outcomes reflect the cognitive bases, values, and experiences of senior decision-makers, while behavioural agency theory emphasizes how executives’ risk preferences, loss aversion, and reference points shape strategic choices under uncertainty. Despite the centrality of cognition in both perspectives, empirical research has largely relied on demographic characteristics as indirect proxies for underlying cognitive processes. This reliance has constrained understanding of how senior leaders collectively perceive risk, process information, and evaluate strategic alternatives. In this study, we re-centre cognition as a core explanatory mechanism by theorising board-level cognitive heterogeneity as a distinct governance and managerial attribute. Drawing on upper echelons and behavioural agency theories, we examine how variation in cognitive traits among directors shapes organisational risk-taking behaviour, particularly through innovation-related strategic investments. Using longitudinal data on large U.S. firms and a novel measure of board-level cognitive heterogeneity, we show that cognitively heterogeneous boards are associated with higher organizational risk-taking behaviour, that this relationship is mediated by innovation investment, and that it is contingent on board structure. By moving beyond demographic proxies, this study advances behavioural and cognitive microfoundations of corporate governance and offers a more precise account of how boards influence strategic outcomes in organisations under uncertainty.

This publication has 54 references indexed in Scilit: