Evaluating Quantitative Measures for Assessing Functional Similarity in Engineering Design
- 28 September 2021
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Mechanical Design
- Vol. 144 (3) , 1-42
Abstract
The development of example-based design support tools, such as those used for design-by-analogy, relies heavily on the computation of similarity between designs. Various vector- and graph-based similarity measures operationalize different principles to assess the similarity of designs. Despite the availability of various types of similarity measures and the widespread adoption of some, these measures have not been tested for cross-measure agreement, especially in a design context. In this paper, several vector- and graph-based similarity measures are tested across two datasets of functional models of products to explore the ways in which they find functionally similar designs. The results show that the network-based measures fundamentally operationalize functional similarity in a different way than vector-based measures. Based upon the findings, we recommend a graph-based similarity measure such as NetSimile in the early stages of design when divergence is desirable and a vector-based measure such as cosine similarity in a period of convergence, when the scope of the desired function implementation is clearer.Keywords
This publication has 28 references indexed in Scilit:
- Function Based Design-by-Analogy: A Functional Vector Approach to Analogical SearchJournal of Mechanical Design, 2014
- An analysis of functional modeling approaches across disciplinesArtificial Intelligence for Engineering Design, Analysis and Manufacturing, 2013
- DeltaCon: A Principled Massive-Graph Similarity Function2013
- The Meaning of “Near” and “Far”: The Impact of Structuring Design Databases and the Effect of Distance of Analogy on Design OutputJournal of Mechanical Design, 2013
- Exploring the Use of Functional Models in Biomimetic Conceptual DesignJournal of Mechanical Design, 2008
- A Quantitative Similarity Metric for Design-by-AnalogyJournal of Mechanical Design, 2002
- Development of a Functional Basis for DesignJournal of Mechanical Design, 1999
- Functional Interdependence and Product Similarity Based on Customer NeedsResearch in Engineering Design, 1999
- Design, analogy, and creativityIEEE Expert, 1997
- A Systematic method for developing function structures, solutions and concept variantsMechanism and Machine Theory, 1990