Inter-Nation Simulation and Contemporary Theories of International Relations
Author:
- 1 September 1966
- journal article
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in American Political Science Review
- Vol. 60 (3) , 562-578
Abstract
The purpose of this article is to compare the Inter-Nation Simulation (INS)—developed by Harold Guetzkow and his colleagues at North-western University and now employed in a number of universities throughout the country—to verbal theories of international relations. It will not be a discussion of the methodological foundations of the simulation but an analytical comparison, primarily on the level of middle-range theory, of the substantive assumptions contained in INS with contemporary international relations theory. Although the primary purpose of this article is to compare the two bodies of theory, it will inevitably raise questions concerning the validity of the Inter-Nation Simulation model and the value of simulation as a general approach to theory. In terms of the former question, it is necessary to remember that the simulators themselves are theorists, albeit a special type. Consequently, the comparison is more a reliability check on simulation and verbal theorists than a validity check on either. The lack of congruence between the assumptions of the simulation and the assumptions of the verbal theorists does not necessarily indicate that the simulation model lacks validity, since the verbal theorist has no monopoly on valid hypotheses. If the author's assumption that simulation is a way of theorizing about international relations is correct, the following comparison should yield some idea about the value of simulation in building a firm theoretical basis for a science of international relations. Forced to be abstract as well as explicit and parsimonious, those using simulation must approach the task of theorizing with a different operational code than the verbal theorists.Keywords
This publication has 29 references indexed in Scilit:
- Conflict resolution through implicit mediationJournal of Conflict Resolution, 1964
- The Four Paradoxes of Nuclear StrategyAmerican Political Science Review, 1964
- Some systemic effects of the spread of nuclear weapons technology: a study through simulation of a multi-nuclear futureJournal of Conflict Resolution, 1963
- Foundations of International PoliticsThe Geographical Journal, 1963
- United Nations Participation as a Learning ExperiencePublic Opinion Quarterly, 1963
- Conflict and DefenseSouthern Economic Journal, 1962
- Foreign Aid: Strategy or Stopgap?Foreign Affairs, 1962
- World PoliticsHarvard Law Review, 1960
- Power and DiplomacyHarvard Law Review, 1959
- Congressional-Executive Relations and the Foreign Policy ConsensusAmerican Political Science Review, 1958