Abstract
Subjective confidence plays an important role in guiding behaviour, especially when objective feedback is unavailable. Systematic misjudgements in confidence can lead to maladaptive behaviours and have been linked to various psychiatric disorders. This study investigated confidence biases in problem gamblers compared to demographically matched control participants. Confidence was examined across different hierarchical levels of metacognition, encompassing local decision confidence, global task performance confidence, and overarching self-esteem. The problem gamblers demonstrated significantly higher local trial and global task confidence compared to control participants, despite lower self-esteem levels and after controlling for objective task performance. This overconfidence bias persisted even after controlling for the transdiagnostic symptom dimensions Anxiety-Depression and Compulsive Behaviour and Intrusive Thought, on which problem gamblers scored higher compared to control participants. The findings suggest a contrast in problem gamblers between elevated confidence in individual decisions and overall lowered self-esteem. Additionally, the findings indicate that these features cannot be solely attributed to increased Compulsive Behaviour and Intrusive Thought and Anxiety-Depression levels. Factors such as diminished sensitivity to objective evidence, cognitive distortions, and cognitive inflexibility in problem gamblers might fuel overconfidence, thereby triggering the cycle of escalating gambling behaviours.