Some traditional methods are more modern than others: Rhythm, withdrawal and the changing meanings of sexual intimacy in Mexican companionate marriage

Authors:
  • JHJennifer S. Hirsch
    Jennifer S. Hirsch
  • CNConstance A. Nathanson
    Constance A. Nathanson

Abstract
This paper discusses distinctions made by married Mexican women in the USA and Mexico between withdrawal and rhythm, as well as differences between women who use these traditional methods and those who use more 'modern' ones. Findings derive from an ethnographic study of gender and reproductive health in a Mexican transnational community. The primary method used was life histories, complemented by 15 months of participant observation. The sample consisted of 13 systematically selected pairs of women; one woman in each pair lived in Atlanta and the other lived in the sending community in western Mexico. While research on fertility regulation frequently classifies rhythm and coitus interruptus as traditional methods, this study showed that those who use these methods may base their classificatory system on other conceptions, including a contraceptive method's ideal properties. Generational changes in ideologies of marriage and intimacy and migration-related changes shape women's ideas about the meaning of sexual intimacy and the symbolic properties of contraceptive methods. This research shows, therefore, that ideology and social context need to be taken into account when exploring how women interpret shared ideas about sexuality.

This publication has 16 references indexed in Scilit: