“Way-Centered” versus “Truth-Centered” Epistemologies
Open Access
- 4 March 2016
- journal article
- research article
- Published by MDPI AG in Education Sciences
- Vol. 6 (1) , 8
Abstract
In recent years, a criticism of “indigenous knowledge” has been that this idea makes sense only in terms of acquaintance (or familiarity) type and practical (or skills-type) knowledge (knowledge-how). Understood in terms of theoretical knowledge (or knowledge-that), however, it faces the arguably insurmountable problems of relativism and superstition. The educational implications of this would be that mere beliefs or opinions unanchored by reason(s), such as bald assertions, superstitions, prejudice and bias, should not be included in the curriculum, at least not under the guise of “knowledge”. Worthy of inclusion are skills and practical knowledge, as are traditional music, art, dance and folklore (qua folklore). Moreover, anything that meets the essential requirements for knowledge-that could in principle be included. Against this understanding of knowledge, and its educational implications, it has been contended that indigenous knowledge places no special emphasis on “belief”, “evidence” or “truth”, but that, according to indigenous practitioners, it is rather “the way” that constitutes knowledge, harmonious interaction and appropriate models of conduct. It has been argued, further, that cognitive states are (to be) seen as “maps”, as useful and practical action-guides. This is why (so the argument for “polycentric epistemologies” or “polycentric global epistemology” goes) divination, rain-making, rain-discarding, shamanism, sorcery, ceremony, ritual, mysticism, etc., must be acknowledged as ways of knowing (and as educationally valuable) alongside animal husbandry, botany, medicine, mathematics, tool-making, and the like. The present paper investigates whether the “way-based” epistemological response is a plausible reply to the “truth-based” critique of indigenous knowledge (systems).Keywords
This publication has 8 references indexed in Scilit:
- Self and Community in a Changing World2010
- ‘In the end, we have the Gatling gun, and they have not’: Future prospects of indigenous knowledgesFutures, 2009
- Social Philosophy in Postcolonial Africa: Some Preliminaries Concerning Communalism and CommunitarianismSouth African Journal of Philosophy, 2008
- The Child's Mind2002
- Truth and Native American epistemologySocial Epistemology, 2001
- Thinking from the Han: Self, Truth and Transcendence in Chinese and Western Culture.Pacific Affairs, 2000
- Thinking Through Confucius1987
- Is Justified True Belief Knowledge?Analysis, 1963