Malignant mesothelioma in females: the institutional failure by WHO and IARC to protect public health
Open Access
- 11 August 2023
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Hamilton Publishing Inc in The Journal of Scientific Practice and Integrity
Abstract
Malignant mesothelioma (MM) is a highly aggressive and difficult-to-diagnose tumor that is almost always caused by asbestos or other asbestiform fibers. Chapter 2 in the Fourth (2015) and Fifth (2021) Editions of the WHO/IARC Classification of Tumours is devoted to the classification and pathologic diagnosis of MM. The authors of these Chapters state that most of the cases of MM in females do not show asbestos as the cause when, in fact, the epidemiologic literature shows that the risk of MM in females exposed to asbestos approaches that in males. While it is correct that the overall incidence of MM in females is lower than in males, the view that MM in females is not caused by asbestos is unsupported. This view results from an inadequate occupational history, the failure to recognize the importance of environmental exposures, and the misrepresentation of published literature by the selection of limited literature and biased bibliographies, often by authors with financial conflicting interests. In this article, we present an example of the institutional failure (1) to protect the public health by permitting the publication of inaccurate statements about the adverse health effects of exposure to asbestos among females, and (2) to make suggested corrections that more accurately reflect reality. Responsibility for correcting the misinformation lies, in our assessment, both with the authors of the erroneous statements and with the editors and publisher of the books that contain these statements. At issue is nothing less than scientific accuracy, the fate of at-risk females for whom early diagnosis could result in improved health outcome, a missed opportunity to promote primary and secondary prevention, and the social injustice of the loss of compensation for females so affected. We describe the steps that we took to correct the inaccuracies, and to expose the dereliction of duty among responsible parties based, at least in part, on what we believe to be undisclosed conflicting interests. Our efforts failed.Keywords
This publication has 56 references indexed in Scilit:
- Comment on ‘Estimating the asbestos-related lung cancer burden from mesothelioma mortality’ – IARC and Chrysotile RisksBritish Journal of Cancer, 2013
- Occupational cancer burden in Great BritainBritish Journal of Cancer, 2012
- Mesothelioma in Qingdao, PRC (2000 – 2007)Journal of Physics: Conference Series, 2009
- Asbestos Fibre Concentrations in the Lungs of Brake Workers: Another LookAnnals of Occupational Hygiene, 2008
- Cancer Mortality and Incidence of Mesothelioma in a Cohort of Wives of Asbestos Workers in Casale Monferrato, ItalyEnvironmental Health Perspectives, 2007
- Cancer risk after cessation of asbestos exposure: a cohort study of Italian asbestos cement workersOccupational and Environmental Medicine, 2007
- Sixty years on: the price of assembling military gas masks in 1940Occupational and Environmental Medicine, 2006
- Asbestos in brakes: Exposure and risk of diseaseAmerican Journal of Industrial Medicine, 2004
- Case 4-1987New England Journal of Medicine, 1987
- Mesothelioma Register 1967-68Occupational and Environmental Medicine, 1974