Conceptualizations of Students with and without Disabilities as Mathematical Problem Solvers in Educational Research: A Critical Review
Open Access
- 1 May 2017
- journal article
- review article
- Published by MDPI AG in Education Sciences
- Vol. 7 (2) , 51
Abstract
Students with disabilities are often framed as “the problem” and have limited opportunities to engage in standards based mathematics, leading to persistent underachievement. In this paper, we investigate a research divide between mathematics educational research for students with and without disabilities, a divide with significant differences in the theoretical orientations and research methodologies used to understand learners. Based on an analysis of 149 mathematics educational research articles published between 2013 and 2015, we found significant differences between articles focused on learners with and without disabilities. For those with disabilities, mathematical problem solving was understood primarily from behavioral and information processing theoretical perspectives, while for those without disabilities, problem solving was understood primarily through constructivist and sociocultural perspectives. While 86% of research on problem-solving including students with disabilities was quantitative, only 35% of research on students without disabilities was quantitative. Fifty percent of problem-solving research on students without disabilities was qualitative, compared to only 6% of research on students with disabilities. Problem solving, then, is studied in very different ways for learners with and without disabilities. Students without disabilities are studied through close analysis of learning, often individual. Students with disabilities are most often studied quantitatively, in groups, with little analysis of individual thinking. By offering only a limited range of methods and theoretical orientations, this research divide reifies deficit constructions of students with disabilities.Keywords
All Related Versions
This publication has 49 references indexed in Scilit:
- The Effect of Tutoring With Nonstandard Equations for Students With Mathematics DifficultyJournal of Learning Disabilities, 2013
- Cognitive Strategies, Working Memory, and Growth in Word Problem Solving in Children With Math DifficultiesJournal of Learning Disabilities, 2013
- Effects of Ratio Strategies Intervention on Knowledge of Ratio Equivalence for Students With Learning DisabilityThe Journal of Special Education, 2013
- Learning in collaborative settings: students building on each other’s ideas to promote their mathematical understandingEducational Studies in Mathematics, 2012
- Learning to solve addition and subtraction word problems in English as an imported languageEducational Studies in Mathematics, 2012
- Consequences, Characteristics, and Causes of Mathematical Learning Disabilities and Persistent Low Achievement in MathematicsJournal of Developmental & Behavioral Pediatrics, 2011
- Cognitive neuroscience meets mathematics education: It takes two to TangoEducational Research Review, 2011
- Alignment of the Intended, Planned, and Enacted Curriculum in General and Special Education and Its Relation to Student AchievementThe Journal of Special Education, 2009
- Who's Counting? A Survey of Mathematics Education Research 1982–1998Journal for Research in Mathematics Education, 2000
- A Review of the Research on Student Conceptions in Mathematics, Science, and ProgrammingReview of Research in Education, 1990