Assessment of Two-Dimensional Separative Systems Using the Nearest Neighbor Distances Approach. Part 2: Separation Quality Aspects
- 3 September 2013
- journal article
- research article
- Published by American Chemical Society (ACS) in Analytical Chemistry
- Vol. 85 (20) , 9459-9468
Abstract
In this paper we propose a method for the evaluation of real separation quality in multidimensional separations based on the nearest neighbor distances (NND). This approach allows us to overcome the principal drawback of the orthogonality measurement which does not evaluate how good the real separation obtained with one system is, especially when compared to another one. Separation quality evaluation takes into account the distances (di(s)) between peaks in whole separation space. The distances between nearest neighbors were calculated in resolution scaled analysis space to overcome statistically different peak widths in each dimension. The obtained separation quality is ranked by harmonic mean (H̅(s)) of the distances di(s). The extent of peak spreading, described by arithmetic mean (A̅(s)), gives an appreciation of the effective analysis space of 2D separation. The classifications of systems obtained with the same retention data using separation quality and orthogonality approaches show important differences in ranking orders depending on two different targets of these evaluations: the separation potential of a 2D system and the divergence of selectivity between both separation directions. This study shows separation quality and orthogonality merit to be evaluated in parallel for the same systems. The other new threshold descriptor, minimal limit distance (dilim) derived from resolution dependent peak capacity scale, was used to predict the separation quality as a function of desired resolution. We also introduce here a composed descriptor for 2D systems: the optimality coefficient (Oc), which may be useful in the 2D separation optimization process. It takes into account the maximization of homogeneity of peak spreading (H̅(s)/A̅(s)) and the minimization of effective analysis space (or compactness, dilim/A̅(s)) terms.Keywords
This publication has 15 references indexed in Scilit:
- A generalization of a chromatographic response function for application in non-target one- and two-dimensional chromatography of complex samplesJournal of Chromatography A, 2012
- A new chromatographic response function for assessing the separation quality in comprehensive two-dimensional liquid chromatographyJournal of Chromatography A, 2012
- Advancement in optimization tactic achieved by newly developed chromatographic response function: Application to LC separation of raloxifene and its impuritiesTalanta, 2011
- A new chromatographic response function for use in size-exclusion chromatography optimization strategies: Application to complex organic mixturesJournal of Chromatography A, 2010
- Development of a resolution metric for comprehensive two-dimensional chromatographyJournal of Chromatography A, 2007
- Quantification of resolution for two‐dimensional separationsJournal of Microcolumn Separations, 1997
- Correction of the resolution function for non-ideal peaksJournal of Chromatography A, 1988
- Criteria for judging the quality of separation in chromatograms containing solvent peaksChromatographia, 1987
- Influence of the peak height distribution on separation performances: Discrimination factor and effective peak capacityChromatographia, 1987
- Optimization strategies for the development of gas-liquid chromatographic methodsJournal of Chromatography A, 1975