Principles of representation throughout the world: Constitutional provisions and electoral systems
- 12 May 2014
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in International Political Science Review
- Vol. 36 (5) , 578-592
Abstract
Focusing on the effects of singular technical elements, electoral system research has neglected the question of whether specific systems are supposed to achieve overarching normative goals. Due to their importance for any polity, such principles of representation are widely assumed to be determined in the constitution. Therefore, a world-wide survey of constitutions presents a promising opportunity to study electoral systems’ general goals in a comparative manner. In providing such a survey and investigating the causes, contents and consequences of constitutional provisions, this analysis shows that constitutional embeddedness of the electoral system is contingent upon factors such as region (with constitutional principles especially typical in Europe and Latin America) and decision-context. Importantly, the ‘proportionality principle’ is much more prone to enter a constitution and receive increased protection than its antipode, the ‘majority principle’. Furthermore, mixed principles calling for a balance between aforementioned extremes exist, suggesting that mixed electoral systems are not always merely technical compromises. Finally, constitutional embeddedness seems to have a context-dependent effect on specific technical elements but generally leads to greater stability of the overall electoral system. The key implication for future research is that the normative principle-dimension of electoral systems has to be considered alongside their technical design.Keywords
This publication has 39 references indexed in Scilit:
- Mind the gap: Do proportional electoral systems foster a more equal representation of women and men, poor and rich?International Political Science Review, 2013
- A quasi-proportional electoral system ‘only for honest men’? The hidden potential for manipulating mixed compensatory electoral systemsInternational Political Science Review, 2012
- The Different Trajectories of Italian Electoral ReformsWest European Politics, 2011
- When Electoral Reform Fails: The Stability of Proportional Representation in Post-Communist DemocraciesWest European Politics, 2011
- Explaining Majoritarian Modification: The Politics of Electoral Reform in the United Kingdom and British ColumbiaInternational Political Science Review, 2010
- To Adopt or Not to Adopt Proportional Representation: The Politics of Institutional ChoiceBritish Journal of Political Science, 2004
- Electoral formulas: A macroscopic perspectiveEuropean Journal of Political Research, 1997
- Choosing Electoral Systems: Proportional, Majoritarian and Mixed SystemsInternational Political Science Review, 1997
- The Principles of Majority and ProportionalityBritish Journal of Political Science, 1971
- II. The Initial Draft and its OriginsAmerican Political Science Review, 1959