Comparing the VSM and Makigami tools in a transactional office environment: exploratory research from an Italian manufacturing company
Authors:
- 19 August 2020
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Total Quality Management & Business Excellence
- Vol. 33 (1-2) , 127-145
Abstract
Lean manufacturing and total quality management (TQM) are often based on mapping tools that support the redesign of processes in manufacturing, as well as in a transactional office environment. Over time, different types of mapping tools have been proposed and customised, especially for TQM applications, although the lean movement supports the well-consolidated value stream mapping (VSM). Although the VSM was created to map typical production processes, it can also be personalised for transactional office processes. Rather than employing a customised VSM, practitioners at times use a particular mapping tool named Makigami, which is linked with the business process reengineering (BPR) tools. Thus, this research investigated Makigami implementation and compared it with the well-known VSM adapted for transactional processes. For the comparison, we analysed a case study of an Italian manufacturing company in which both the mapping tools had been implemented in the technical department. The results indicated that Makigami seems to be a better vehicle for mapping a transactional office process, in comparison with the VSM, which must be altered in many ways from the original version. However, we found positive and negative features of both tools. Further, it seems that the tools could be integrated to work together.Keywords
This publication has 34 references indexed in Scilit:
- A Healthcare Lean Six Sigma System for Postanesthesia Care Unit Workflow ImprovementQuality Management in Health Care, 2011
- The evolution of the effective process framework: A model for redesigning business processesPerformance Improvement Journal, 2009
- Know your client's businessPerformance Improvement Journal, 2009
- Document Analysis as a Qualitative Research MethodQualitative Research Journal, 2009
- An evaluation of the value stream mapping toolBusiness Process Management Journal, 2008
- Software requirements validation via task analysisJournal of Systems and Software, 2002
- Formalization and verification of event-driven process chainsInformation and Software Technology, 1999
- The seven value stream mapping toolsInternational Journal of Operations & Production Management, 1997
- Reengineering the corporation: A manifesto for business revolutionBusiness Horizons, 1993
- Conducting case study research in operations managementJournal of Operations Management, 1993