Offline Digital Education for Postregistration Health Professions: Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis by the Digital Health Education Collaboration
Open Access
- 24 April 2019
- journal article
- review article
- Published by JMIR Publications Inc. in Journal of Medical Internet Research
- Vol. 21 (4) , e12968
Abstract
Background: The shortage and disproportionate distribution of health care workers worldwide is further aggravated by the inadequacy of training programs, difficulties in implementing conventional curricula, deficiencies in learning infrastructure, or a lack of essential equipment. Offline digital education has the potential to improve the quality of health professions education.Objective: The primary objective of this systematic review was to evaluate the effectiveness of offline digital education compared with various controls in improving learners’ knowledge, skills, attitudes, satisfaction, and patient-related outcomes. The secondary objectives were (1) to assess the cost-effectiveness of the interventions and (2) to assess adverse effects of the interventions on patients and learners.Methods: We searched 7 electronic databases and 2 trial registries for randomized controlled trials published between January 1990 and August 2017. We used Cochrane systematic review methods.Results: A total of 27 trials involving 4618 individuals were included in this systematic review. Meta-analyses found that compared with no intervention, offline digital education (CD-ROM) may increase knowledge in nurses (standardized mean difference [SMD]=1.88; 95% CI 1.14 to 2.62; participants=300; studies=3; I2=80%; low certainty evidence). A meta-analysis of 2 studies found that compared with no intervention, the effects of offline digital education (computer-assisted training [CAT]) on nurses and physical therapists’ knowledge were uncertain (SMD 0.55; 95% CI –0.39 to 1.50; participants=64; I2=71%; very low certainty evidence). A meta-analysis of 2 studies found that compared with traditional learning, a PowerPoint presentation may improve the knowledge of patient care personnel and pharmacists (SMD 0.76; 95% CI 0.29 to 1.23; participants=167; I2=54%; low certainty evidence). A meta-analysis of 4 studies found that compared with traditional training, the effects of computer-assisted training on skills in community (mental health) therapists, nurses, and pharmacists were uncertain (SMD 0.45; 95% CI –0.35 to 1.25; participants=229; I2=88%; very low certainty evidence). A meta-analysis of 4 studies found that compared with traditional training, offline digital education may have little effect or no difference on satisfaction scores in nurses and mental health therapists (SMD –0.07; 95% CI –0.42 to 0.28, participants=232; I2=41%; low certainty evidence). A total of 2 studies found that offline digital education may have little or no effect on patient-centered outcomes when compared with blended learning. For skills and attitudes, the results were mixed and inconclusive. None of the studies reported adverse or unintended effects of the interventions. Only 1 study reported costs of interventions. The risk of bias was predominantly unclear and the certainty of the evidence ranged from low to very low.Conclusions: There is some evidence to support the effectiveness of offline digital education in improving learners’ knowledge and insufficient quality and quantity evidence for the other outcomes. Future high-quality studies are needed to increase generalizability and inform use of this modality of education.Keywords
All Related Versions
This publication has 55 references indexed in Scilit:
- Perineal Assessment and Repair Longitudinal Study (PEARLS): a matched-pair cluster randomized trialBMC Medicine, 2013
- Evaluation of a theory-driven e-learning intervention for future oral healthcare providers on secondary prevention of disordered eating behaviorsHealth Education Research, 2013
- Effect of e-Learning and Repeated Performance Feedback on Spirometry Test Quality in Family Practice: A Cluster TrialThe Annals of Family Medicine, 2011
- Striking the right balance: health workforce retention in remote and rural areasBulletin of the World Health Organization, 2010
- Electronic continuing education in the health professions: An update on evidence from RCTsJournal of Continuing Education in the Health Professions, 2009
- Technology-Based Training in Cognitive Behavioral Therapy for Substance Abuse CounselorsSubstance Abuse, 2006
- Improving the safety of medication administration using an interactive CD-ROM programAmerican Journal of Health-System Pharmacy, 2006
- The effectiveness of computer-aided learning in teaching orthodontics: A review of the literatureAmerican Journal of Orthodontics and Dentofacial Orthopedics, 2005
- Pedagogical underpinnings of computer‐based learningJournal of Advanced Nursing, 2004
- Hypertext Computer-Assisted Instruction for Geriatric Physical TherapistsPhysical & Occupational Therapy In Geriatrics, 1992