When emotionality trumps reason: A study of individual processing style and juror bias
Open Access
- 25 November 2010
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Behavioral Sciences & the Law
- Vol. 28 (6) , 850-877
Abstract
“Cognitive Experiential Self Theory” (CEST) postulates that information‐processing proceeds through two pathways, a rational one and an experiential one. The former is characterized by an emphasis on analysis, fact, and logical argument, whereas the latter is characterized by emotional and personal experience. We examined whether individuals influenced by the experiential system (E‐processors) are more susceptible to extralegal biases (e.g. defendant attractiveness) than those influenced by the rational system (R‐processors). Participants reviewed a criminal trial transcript and defendant profile and determined verdict, sentencing, and extralegal susceptibility. Although E‐processors and R‐processors convicted attractive defendants at similar rates, E‐processors were more likely to convict less attractive defendants. Whereas R‐processors did not sentence attractive and less attractive defendants differently, E‐processors gave more lenient sentences to attractive defendants and harsher sentences to less attractive defendants. E‐processors were also more likely to report that extralegal factors would change their verdicts. Further, the degree to which emotionality trumped rationality within an individual, as measured by a novel scoring method, linearly correlated with harsher sentences and extralegal influence. In sum, the results support an “unattractive harshness” effect during guilt determination, an attraction leniency effect during sentencing and increased susceptibility to extralegal factors within E‐processors. Copyright © 2010 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.Keywords
This publication has 58 references indexed in Scilit:
- Generalization of Affective Learning About Faces to Perceptually Similar FacesPsychological Science, 2010
- Assessing individual differences in adolescents’ preference for rational and experiential cognitionPersonality and Individual Differences, 2008
- Paranormal beliefs, schizotypy, and thinking styles among teachers and future teachersPersonality and Individual Differences, 2005
- Jury Sentencing in Noncapital Cases: Comparing Severity and Variance with Judicial Sentences in Two StatesJournal of Empirical Legal Studies, 2005
- Jury Sentencing as Democratic PracticeVirginia Law Review, 2003
- The verdict on jury trials for juveniles: the effects of defendant's age on trial outcomesBehavioral Sciences & the Law, 2003
- Some individual differences in perception of the evidence and the verdict choicePsychology, Crime & Law, 1998
- DEFENDANTS' CHARACTERISTICS OF ATTRACTIVENESS, RACE, AND SEX AND SENTENCING DECISIONSPsychological Reports, 1997
- The impact of litigants' baby-facedness and attractiveness on adjudications in small claims courts.Law and Human Behavior, 1991
- The effect of physical appearance on the judgment of guilt, interpersonal attraction, and severity of recommended punishment in a simulated jury taskJournal of Research in Personality, 1974