Selection of a Method to Rate the Strength of Scientific Evidence for AORN Recommendations
Authors:
- Victoria M. SteelmanVSVictoria M. Steelman
- Theresa PapeTPTheresa Pape
- Cecil A. KingCKCecil A. King
- Paula GralingPGPaula Graling
- Kathleen B. GabersonKGKathleen B. Gaberson
- 30 April 2011
- journal article
- Published by Wiley in AORN Journal
- Vol. 93 (4) , 433-444
Abstract
The use of scientific evidence to support national recommendations about clinical decisions has become an expectation of multidisciplinary health care organizations. The objectives of this project were to identify the most applicable evidence-rating method for perioperative nursing practice, evaluate the reliability of this method for perioperative nursing recommendations, and identify barriers and facilitators to adoption of this method for AORN recommendations. A panel of perioperative nurse experts evaluated 46 evidence-rating systems for quality, quantity, and consistency. We rated the methods that fully covered all three domains on five aspects of applicability to perioperative nursing practice recommendations. The Oncology Nursing Society's method was rated highest for all five aspects of applicability, and interrater reliability of this method for perioperative recommendations was 100%. Potential barriers to implementation of the rating method include knowledge deficit, staff resources, resistance to change, and fear of showing that lower levels of evidence support some recommendations. Facilitators included education, resource allocation, and starting small. Barriers and facilitators will be considered by the implementation team that will develop a plan to achieve integration of evidence rating into AORN documents. The AORN Board of Directors approved adoption of this method in June 2010.Keywords
This publication has 7 references indexed in Scilit:
- ASPAN's Evidence-Based Clinical Practice Guideline for the Promotion of Perioperative NormothermiaJournal of PeriAnesthesia Nursing, 2009
- Upgrading the American Association of Critical-Care Nurses' Evidence-Leveling HierarchyAmerican Journal of Critical Care, 2009
- GRADE: an emerging consensus on rating quality of evidence and strength of recommendationsBMJ, 2008
- Updating the Stetler Model of research utilization to facilitate evidence-based practiceNursing Outlook, 2001
- A Practical Approach to Evidence GradingThe Joint Commission Journal on Quality Improvement, 2000
- Users' Guides to the Medical LiteratureJAMA, 2000
- Developing an evidence-based guide to community preventive services—methods11Some of this material has been previously published in: Shefer A, Briss P, Rodewald L, et al. Improving immunization coverage rates: An evidence-based review of the literature. Epidemiologic Reviews 1999;20:96–142.22The names and affiliations of the Task Force members are listed on page v of this supplement and at http://www.thecommunityguide.orgAmerican Journal of Preventive Medicine, 2000