Investigating the Impacts of Tillage and Cover Crop Management on Soil Compaction in Long‐Term Agricultural Production Sites Using a Home‐Built Dynamic Penetrometer
Authors:
- Gunther LiebhardGLGunther Liebhard
- Stefan StrohmeierSSStefan Strohmeier
- Christine StumppCSChristine Stumpp
- Andreas KlikAKAndreas Klik
- Reinhard NolzRNReinhard Nolz
- Csilla HudekCHCsilla Hudek
- Xiaoping ZhangXZXiaoping Zhang
- Yangyang LiYLYangyang Li
- Weinan SunWSWeinan Sun
- Laura ZavattaroLaura Zavattaro
- Octavian P. ChiriacOCOctavian P. Chiriac
Open Access
- 1 April 2026
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Soil Use and Management
- Vol. 42 (2) , e70246
Abstract
Agricultural management produces soil compaction depending on intensity of use, specific management and soil properties. We used an adapted, home‐built dynamic penetrometer to evaluate 20 long‐term sites of arable land, tree orchards, vineyards and grassland in Europe and China, each with different tillage and cover crop strategies. To ensure comparable results across all sites, we pre‐tested different penetrometer settings in the laboratory to cover all local conditions and provided Standard Operating Procedures. The laboratory tests showed that different settings in terms of falling hammer height and cone angle produced replicable results, and that narrow plough pans (3 cm) could be detected, even though their density was underestimated by 50%. The pre‐tests also demonstrated the dependence of the measurements on soil water content and texture, even under preset conditions close to field capacity. Consequently, the effects of different management practices were only compared directly for each site individually. The field study showed that tillage had a greater effect on penetration resistance than different cover crop systems and intensity. The majority of the more intensively tilled fields showed penetration resistance that was up to 3 MPa lower, at least partially, up to the ploughing depth compared to less intensively tilled fields. However, in only 27% of the fields, the no‐till or reduced‐till management led to an SPR greater than 2.5 MPa, indicating harmful compaction, compared to conventional management. The effects of cover crops on soil compaction were unclear with differences observed between different mixtures at only one site. Nevertheless, unlike bare soil, cover crops increased penetration resistance in the tillage horizon and reduced infiltration capacity in 75% of the fields investigated. Trends depending on management practices varied due to local soil properties. We therefore recommend farmers to include penetrometer measurements in their routine to recognize soil compaction in time and apply tailored mitigation strategies.Keywords
Funding Information
- Horizon 2020 Framework Programme (101000224)
This publication has 51 references indexed in Scilit:
- A spatial machine-learning model for predicting crop water stress index for precision irrigation of vineyardsComputers and Electronics in Agriculture, 2024
- Root and root‐derived biopore interactions in soils: A reviewJournal of Plant Nutrition and Soil Science, 2022
- Effects of tillage systems on soil organic carbon and some soil physical propertiesLand Degradation & Development, 2022
- Cover crop impacts on soil physical properties: A reviewSoil Science Society of America Journal, 2020
- Modelling soil erosion reduction by Mahonia aquifolium on hillslopes in Hungary: The impact of soil stabilization by rootsCATENA, 2014
- Modeling and correction of soil penetration resistance for varying soil water contentGeoderma, 2011
- Bodengefüge gegen Verdichtungen schützen – Lösungsansätze für den Schutz landwirtschaftlich genutzter BödenJournal of Plant Nutrition and Soil Science, 2006
- Soil structure and management: a reviewGeoderma, 2005
- The environmental consequences of adopting conservation tillage in Europe: reviewing the evidenceAgriculture, Ecosystems & Environment, 2004
- How do roots penetrate strong soil?2003