Purpose. To synthesize substrate-specific evidence on bonding to caries-affected, eroded, and sclerotic dentin and integrate it with current evidence on the athlete oral environment to define implications for adhesive restorative care in sports dentistry. Methods. A targeted narrative review used PubMed/MEDLINE, citation chaining, and full-text verification. Systematic reviews and meta-analyses were prioritized; a separate contextual search addressed athletes, sports nutrition, saliva, caries, erosive tooth wear, and restorative dentistry through 6 September 2026. Results. Caries-affected and eroded dentin generally show lower laboratory bond strength than sound dentin, while management of sclerotic surfaces remains material- and protocol-dependent. Contemporary evidence does not support a universal additional phosphoric-acid etching rule. A 2025 meta-analysis estimated caries prevalence at 44.4% and dental erosion at 36.5% among elite athletes, with high heterogeneity; no athlete-specific bonding trial was identified. Conclusions. Altered dentin should be managed according to substrate biology and adhesive chemistry. Sports-related exposures may increase the clinical likelihood of encountering carious or eroded substrates, but current evidence does not justify sport-specific bonding protocols.