THE CORPORATE MANAGEMENT FRAMEWORK AS ADMINISTRATIVE SCIENCE: A CRITIQUE
Author:
- Mark ConsidineMCMark Considine
- 18 March 1988
- journal article
- Published by Wiley in Australian Journal of Public Administration
- Vol. 47 (1) , 4-18
Abstract
A corporate management framework has been the basis for a transformation of Australian public administration in recent years. Program budgeting, corporate planning, performance contracts, program evaluation and new forms of efficiency scrutiny are among the techniques introduced. They stem from a dominant paradigm of technical and instrumental rationality, within which a framework of practical remedies and technologies of power carries the corporate management label. Four concepts underly this framework and its techniques: the product format, instrumentalism, integration and purposive action. The framework has fundamental problems. The product format is inappropriate for many public services and overvalues quantifiable, single‐purpose outputs while denigrating claims of worth and effectiveness made on non‐economic grounds; instrumentalism ignores the political dimensions of public organisations; integration denies the value of decentralised forms of service development and delivery and, paradoxically, contradicts current private management precepts; and purposive action displays an unwarranted optimism about the potency of technical rationality under central direction. The four principles must be reviewed as offering few prospects for genuine and lasting reform.Keywords
This publication has 6 references indexed in Scilit:
- SCALE ECONOMIES AND IRON LAWS: MERGERS AND DEMERGERS IN WHITEHALL 1971–1984Public Administration, 1985
- Reorganization Reconsidered: An Empirical Approach to the Departmentalization ProblemPublic Administration Review, 1979
- Towards a Sociology of Organisational StructureThe Sociological Review, 1978
- The political economy of social service rationalization: A developmental viewCrime, Law and Social Change, 1978
- Tactics of Lateral Relationship: The Purchasing AgentAdministrative Science Quarterly, 1962
- A Behavioral Model of Rational ChoiceThe Quarterly Journal of Economics, 1955