Pronoun co-referencing errors: Challenges for generativist and usage-based accounts
- 1 January 2009
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Walter de Gruyter GmbH in Cognitive Linguistics
- Vol. 20 (3) , 599-626
Abstract
This study tests accounts of co-reference errors whereby children allow “Mama Bear” and “her” to co-refer in sentences like “Mama Bear is washing her” (Chien and Wexler, Language Acquisition 1: 225–295, 1990). 63 children aged 4;6, 5;6 and 6;6 participated in a truth-value judgment task augmented with a sentence production component. There were three major finding: 1) contrary to predictions of most generativist accounts, children accepted co-reference even in cases of bound anaphora e.g., “Every girl is washing her” 2) contrary to Thornton and Wexler (Principle B, VP Ellipsis and Interpretation in Child Grammar, The MIT Press, 1999), errors did not appear to occur because children understood referring expressions to be denoting the same person in different guises 3) contrary to usage-based accounts, errors were less likely in sentences that contained lower as opposed to higher frequency verbs. Error rates also differed significantly according to pronoun type (“him”, “her”, “them”). These challenging results are discussed in terms of possible processing explanations.Keywords
This publication has 23 references indexed in Scilit:
- When Production Precedes Comprehension: An Optimization Approach to the Acquisition of PronounsLanguage Acquisition, 2006
- Learning antecedents for anaphoric oneCognition, 2004
- Learnability and linguistic performanceJournal of Child Language, 2004
- The Interpretation of Pronouns in Spanish Language Acquisition and Breakdown: Evidence for the "Principle B Delay" as a Non-Unitary PhenomenonLanguage Acquisition, 2003
- Clausal backgrounding and pronominal reference: A functionalist approach to c-commandLanguage and Cognitive Processes, 2002
- Binding and Coreference in Norwegian Child LanguageLanguage Acquisition, 2000
- Children's Knowledge of Binding and Coreference: Evidence from Spontaneous SpeechLanguage, 1994
- Exploring the boundary between syntax and pragmatics: relevance and the binding of pronounsJournal of Child Language, 1994
- Cognitive Status and the Form of Referring Expressions in DiscourseLanguage, 1993
- Children's Knowledge of Locality Conditions in Binding as Evidence for the Modularity of Syntax and PragmaticsLanguage Acquisition, 1990