Expanded Assessment Study Examining the Citation Patterns from Traditional and Nontraditional Institutions and Their Effect upon the Quality of Doctoral Dissertation Reference Lists
Authors:
- 24 February 2009
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Library Administration
- Vol. 49 (1-2) , 137-159
Abstract
This study used citation analysis in conjunction with a subjective rubric with five validated criteria to assess the quality of a purposive sample of 452 education dissertation reference lists produced at a nontraditional institution from six doctoral programs. These programs used a variety of distance education models. The citations were then compared with the 100 reference lists selected from doctoral education programs at 10 traditional institutions. Criteria included the breadth of resources, depth of the literature review as shown through the citing of critical historical and theoretical works, depth as demonstrated through the scholarliness of citations chosen, currency, and relevancy. The study discusses how the expanded sample of traditional reference lists continued to demonstrate consistent patterns. In contrast, although the sample of reference lists from distance education programs was much expanded, the patterns of the subsets of reference lists at the nontraditional institution were significantly diverse. The patterns of 35 doctoral reference lists from another for-profit, nontraditional institution known for providing distance education were also examined to compare the results of the two nontraditional programs. Possible reasons for differences in citation patterns by traditional and nontraditional programs are discussed, and the possible role of distance education and program criteria are examined for insights they offer into the use of citation analysis as an assessment tool of the library research skills of doctoral students.Keywords
This publication has 16 references indexed in Scilit:
- A Canadian Perspective on the Uncertain Future of Distance EducationDistance Education, 2005
- Does the medium matter?: A comparison of a Web-based tutorial with face-to-face library instruction on education students' self-efficacy levels and learning outcomesResearch Strategies, 2004
- Sense of community in a higher education television-based distance education programEducational Technology Research and Development, 2003
- Assessing Outcomes with Nursing Research Assignments and Citation Analysis of StudentBibliographiesThe Reference Librarian, 2003
- Comparing Web-Based and Classroom-Based LearningJournal of Research on Technology in Education, 2001
- Check the citation: library instruction and student paper bibliographiesResearch Strategies, 2000
- The Comparative Suitability Of Three ICT Distance Learning Methodologies For College Level InstructionEducational Media International, 2000
- Assessing undergraduate use of electronic resources: A quantitative analysis of works citedResearch Strategies, 1997
- A reply: Media and methodsEducational Technology Research and Development, 1994
- Journal citations in Master's Theses: One measurement of a journal collectionJournal of the American Society for Information Science, 1973