Why bother with controlled-environment phenotyping when field phenomics is already up and running?
- 25 July 2026
- journal article
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Journal of Experimental Botany
Abstract
Plant phenomics has undergone rapid development over the past two decades, driven by advances in imaging, robotics, artificial intelligence, and data analysis. Whilst field phenotyping is increasingly operational and scalable, the relevance of controlled-environment (CE) phenotyping is questioned because of concerns regarding the limited transferability of results to agricultural conditions. This Expert View first addresses the limitations and risks of using CEs as a surrogate of outdoor conditions. However, we argue that CEs enable the disentangling of interacting environmental drivers, allowing causal analysis of plant responses to multiple abiotic and biotic stresses. CE platforms also provide access to complex traits that are difficult or impossible to measure in the field, whilst providing a robust framework, in combination with field approaches, to interpret and predict field performance. We further discuss contexts where CEs remain indispensable, including quarantine and biosafety regulations, together with emerging opportunities for agricultural innovation. Whilst limitations of CE systems are acknowledged, including issues of extrapolation, pot effects, environmental realism, and the indispensable need for rigorous envirotyping, we conclude that CE phenotyping should be regarded as an enabling analytical framework that complements and strengthens field phenomics for crop adaptation research under climate change.Keywords
Funding Information
- PHENOME-EMPHASIS
This publication has 135 references indexed in Scilit:
- Early detection of banana fusarium wilt caused by Fusarium oxysporum f. sp. cubense using hyperspectral with a metric learning strategyPest Management Science, 2026
- Artificial intelligence‐powered plant phenomics: Progress, challenges, and opportunitiesThe Plant Phenome Journal, 2025
- The future role of regional research infrastructures and networks toward the global plant phenotyping communityThe Plant Phenome Journal, 2025
- A maize landrace introgression library reveals a negative effect of root‐to‐shoot ratio on water‐use efficiencyThe Plant Genome, 2025
- Identification by GWAS of marker haplotypes relevant to breed potato for Globodera pallida resistanceTheoretical and Applied Genetics, 2025
- Optimizing Crop Production With Plant Phenomics Through High‐Throughput Phenotyping and AI in Controlled EnvironmentsFood and Energy Security, 2025
- High-dimensional multi-omics measured in controlled conditions are useful for maize platform and field trait predictionsTheoretical and Applied Genetics, 2024
- Opportunities and limits of controlled-environment plant phenotyping for climate response traitsTheoretical and Applied Genetics, 2021
- Carbon isotope composition, water use efficiency, and drought sensitivity are controlled by a common genomic segment in maizeTheoretical and Applied Genetics, 2018
- Plant Breeding for Water-Limited Environments2011