Predicting and controlling the reactivity of immune cell populations against cancer

Authors:

Abstract
Heterogeneous cell populations form an interconnected network that determine their collective output. One example of such a heterogeneous immune population is tumor‐infiltrating lymphocytes (TILs), whose output can be measured in terms of its reactivity against tumors. While the degree of reactivity varies considerably between different TILs, ranging from null to a potent response, the underlying network that governs the reactivity is poorly understood. Here, we asked whether one can predict and even control this reactivity. To address this we measured the subpopulation compositions of 91 TILs surgically removed from 27 metastatic melanoma patients. Despite the large number of subpopulations compositions, we were able to computationally extract a simple set of subpopulation‐based rules that accurately predict the degree of reactivity. This raised the conjecture of whether one could control reactivity of TILs by manipulating their subpopulation composition. Remarkably, by rationally enriching and depleting selected subsets of subpopulations, we were able to restore anti‐tumor reactivity to nonreactive TILs. Altogether, this work describes a general framework for predicting and controlling the output of a cell mixture. ### Synopsis A major challenge in molecular and cellular biology is to understand the collective function of cell populations made of different cell types that have complex networks of direct and indirect cell–cell interactions. Can simple rules be found to understand and even control the function of such complex and heterogeneous populations? To address this question, we used as a model system a cell population mixture, called tumor‐infiltrating lymphocytes (TILs). TILs are an immune population composed of different lymphocytic subpopulations that are derived from a tumor mass and have specificity and potential reactivity against the tumor (1). Presently, TILs are used in a clinical protocol called adoptive cell transfer for the treatment of metastatic melanoma (2). Despite their clinical importance, little is known about the underlying composition and cellular interactions that govern the degree of TIL reactivity against melanoma and consequentially on how to control their reactivity. We began this study by examining the composition and reactivity of 91 TILs that were extracted from surgically removed metastatic tumors of 27 different melanoma patients. We characterized the cellular composition of each of these TILs by measuring the frequencies of over 100 different subpopulations that reside in them by using multicolor flow cytometry. Each of the subpopulations showed a unique set of receptors or membrane markers. The collective output of each TIL was defined in terms of its IFN‐γ secretion, which is a major criterion for determining T‐cell activity, after incubation with autologous melanoma. This procedure was used to classify 39 TIL cultures as reactive and 52 as nonreactive. First, we asked whether any individual subpopulation can effectively predict the collective reactivity of the entire population. In particular, subpopulations containing the CD4+ and CD8+ receptors were examined due to their well‐established role in T‐cell responses. We found that none of the individual subpopulations examined in this study, including CD4+ and CD8+, could accurately predict the collective response of the heterogeneous TIL population to autologous cancer cells. Next, we turned to examine the similarity between different TILs by comparing their sets of subpopulation frequencies, which we term ‘subpopulation signatures.’ Unsupervised clustering of the subpopulation signatures revealed that despite the large number of possible subpopulation combinations TILs tend to fall into one of two main clusters ([Figure 3][1]). Interestingly, the first cluster was highly enriched with nonreactive TILs, whereas the other was enriched with reactive ones ( P <103). These results suggest that although individual subpopulations are not accurate predictors, by using a combination of several subpopulations frequencies one may be able to predict the collective TIL reactivity. To test this, we applied decision tree algorithms on the subpopulation signatures and were able to extract a simple set of subpopulation‐based rules that accurately predicted TIL reactivity (89% total accuracy). Furthermore, by using a linear model that is based on balance between two CD8+ subsets with antagonistic effects, we could predict not only whether a TIL is reactive but its actual level of reactivity in terms of INF‐γ secretion. These results raised the conjecture of whether one could control reactivity of TILs by rationally manipulating their subpopulation fractions using the subpopulation‐based rules. To examine this, we rationally manipulated the subpopulation frequencies of a fresh cohort of 12 nonreactive TILs by selective enrichment and depletion of specific subpopulations. Remarkably, this manipulation restored the anti‐tumor reactivity of 9 of the 12 nonreactive TILs ([Figure 5][2]). Additionally, by depleting and enriching the complementary set subpopulations, we were able to turn a fresh cohort of five reactive TILs into nonreactive ones. These results show the effectiveness of using a TIL's subpopulation signature to predict and even control its reactivity against tumors. The scheme presented in this work may be extended to predict and control the outputs of other types of heterogeneous cell populations in fields such as stem cells, tumor immunology, and tissue engineering. Mol Syst Biol. 5: 265 [1]: #F3 [2]: #F5

This publication has 28 references indexed in Scilit: