A 3D Finite‐Element Modelling Investigation of Soil Thermal Imbalance and Recovery Strategies in Energy Pile Systems
Preprint
- 23 February 2026
- preprint
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Abstract
Energy piles present a cost-effective alternative to traditional borehole systems to provide energy-efficient heating for buildings. However, in heating-dominated climates, the continuous extraction of heat creates a long-term thermal imbalance, leading to progressive soil temperature degradation and declining system efficiency. This study presents a coupled three-dimensional finite element analysis of a previously developed and validated numerical model, comparing it with actual experimental data. This study evaluates the effectiveness of three thermal recovery strategies over five years: natural recovery through scheduled system stoppage, passive recovery using ground air heat exchangers (GAHEs), and active recovery via ground water heat exchangers (GWHEs). Results show that active GWHE recovery maintained outlet temperatures up to 2 °C higher than systems without recovery. Natural recovery provided negligible improvement, while GAHEs modestly raised seasonal temperature extremes by 1–2 °C but failed to maintain thermal equilibrium. Parametric analysis showed that increasing the pipe diameter or flow rate beyond 2–3 cm and 3–4.5 L/min, respectively, yielded less than 0.5°C additional benefit. Extending the recovery duration or adding multiple loops also offered minimal gains because of thermal overlap. A single 2 cm pipe at 3 L/min, maintained outlet temperatures 32% higher than the baseline. The impact of this work is to provide insights into mitigating long-term thermal imbalance in heating-dominant energy piles, preserving efficiency, extending system lifespan, and informing future standards.Keywords
This publication has 30 references indexed in Scilit:
- Zoning operation of energy piles to alleviate the soil thermal imbalance of ground source heat pump systemsEnergy and Built Environment, 2023
- Driven precast concrete geothermal energy piles: Current state of knowledgeBuilding and Environment, 2022
- Experimental study of a domestic solar-assisted ground source heat pump with seasonal underground thermal energy storage through shallow boreholesApplied Thermal Engineering, 2019
- Thermal imbalance due to application of geothermal energy piles and mitigation strategies for sustainable development in cold regions: a reviewInnovative Infrastructure Solutions, 2019
- Effects of the geothermal load on the ground temperature recovery in a ground heat exchangerEnergy and Buildings, 2017
- Embodied energy in residential buildings-towards the nearly zero energy building: A literature reviewBuilding and Environment, 2016
- Energy and geotechnical behaviour of energy piles for different design solutionsApplied Thermal Engineering, 2015
- Experimental investigations of the performance of a solar-ground source heat pump system operated in heating modesEnergy and Buildings, 2015
- Study on intermittent operation strategies of a hybrid ground-source heat pump system with double-cooling towers for hotel buildingsEnergy and Buildings, 2014
- Long-term performance of heat exchanger pilesActa Geotechnica, 2014