Surface texture analysis in Toothfrax and MountainsMap® SSFA module: Different software packages, different results?
- 2 December 2022
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Peer Community In in Peer Community Journal
- Vol. 2
Abstract
The scale-sensitive fractal analysis (SSFA) of dental microwear textures is traditionally performed using the software Toothfrax. SSFA has been recently integrated to the software MountainsMap® as an optional module. Meanwhile, Toothfrax support has ended. Before switching to the new module, the outputs between the two software packages must be compared for consistency. We have performed such a test using Bayesian modelling on three datasets including dental surfaces of sheep (Merceron, Ramdarshan, et al., 2016) and guinea pigs (Winkler, Schulz-Kornas, Kaiser, Cuyper, et al., 2019) from controlled feeding experiments, as well as surfaces of quartzite and flint flakes used in an actualistic archeological experiment on cleaning procedures (Pedergnana, Calandra, Bob, et al., 2020). We found that the two software packages calculate significantly different values for the SSFA parameters epLsar, Asfc, HAsfc9 and R2, even when the same settings are used. Nevertheless, the treatments (different diets or cleaning procedures) are discriminated similarly within each dataset. While the new software module is as good as the original software to differentiate treatments, our results imply that the outputs from the two software packages are not directly comparable and, as such, cannot be merged. Surface texture analysts should therefore consider re-analyzing published surfaces before integrating them in their studies.Keywords
This publication has 109 references indexed in Scilit:
- Teasing apart the contributions of hard dietary items on 3D dental microtextures in primatesJournal of Human Evolution, 2012
- Discrimination of surface wear on obsidian tools using LSCM and RelA: pilot study results (area‐scale analysis of obsidian tool surfaces)Scanning, 2011
- Applying tribology to teeth of hoofed mammalsScanning, 2010
- Incisor microwear textures of five bioarcheological groupsInternational Journal of Osteoarchaeology, 2009
- QUANTIFICATION AND DISCRIMINATION OF LITHIC USE‐WEAR: SURFACE PROFILE MEASUREMENTS AND LENGTH‐SCALE FRACTAL ANALYSIS*Archaeometry, 2009
- Dental microwear texture analysis: technical considerationsJournal of Human Evolution, 2006
- Dental microwear texture analysis shows within-species diet variability in fossil homininsNature, 2005
- Quantification of Dental Microwear by Tandem Scanning Confocal Microscopy and Scale‐Sensitive Fractal AnalysesScanning, 2003
- ISSUES IN MODELING MACHINED SURFACE TEXTURESMachining Science and Technology, 2000
- Fractal analysis of topographic data by the patchwork methodWear, 1993