A comparison of methods for whole-genome QTL mapping using dense markers in four livestock species
Authors:
- Andres LegarraALAndres Legarra
- Pascal CroiseauPCPascal Croiseau
- Marie SanchezMSMarie Sanchez
- Simon TeyssèdreSTSimon Teyssèdre
- Guillaume SalléGSGuillaume Sallé
- Sophie AllaisSASophie Allais
- Sébastien FritzSFSébastien Fritz
- Carole MorenoCMCarole Moreno
- Anne RicardARAnne Ricard
- Jean-Michel ElsenJEJean-Michel Elsen
Open Access
- 1 January 2015
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in Genetics Selection Evolution
- Vol. 47 (1) , 1-10
Abstract
With dense genotyping, many choices exist for methods to detect quantitative trait loci (QTL) in livestock populations. However, no across-species study has been conducted on the performance of different methods using real data. We compared three methods that correct for relatedness either implicitly or explicitly: linkage and linkage disequilibrium haplotype-based analysis (LDLA), efficient mixed-model association (EMMA) analysis, and Bayesian whole-genome regression (BayesC). We analyzed one chromosome in each of five datasets (dairy cattle, beef cattle, sheep, horses, and pigs) using real genotypes based on dense single nucleotide polymorphisms and phenotypes. The P values corrected for multiple testing or Bayes factors greater than 150 were considered to be significant. To complete the real data study, we also simulated quantitative trait loci (QTL) for the same datasets based on the real genotypes. Several scenarios were chosen, with different QTL effects and linkage disequilibrium patterns. A pseudo-null statistical distribution was chosen to make the significance thresholds comparable across methods. For the real data, the three methods generally agreed within 1 or 2 cM for the locations of QTL regions and disagreed when no signals were significant (e.g. in pigs). For certain datasets, LDLA had more significant signals than EMMA or BayesC, but they were concentrated around the same peaks. Therefore, the three methods detected approximately the same number of QTL regions. For the simulated data, LDLA was slightly less powerful and accurate than either EMMA or BayesC but this depended strongly on how thresholds were set in the simulations. All three methods performed similarly for real and simulated data. No method was clearly superior across all datasets or for any particular dataset. For computational efficiency and ease of interpretation, EMMA is recommended, but using more than one method is suggested.Keywords
This publication has 33 references indexed in Scilit:
- Genome-wide efficient mixed-model analysis for association studiesNature Genetics, 2012
- Detecting Rare Variant Associations by Identity-by-Descent Mapping in Case-Control StudiesGenetics, 2012
- Extension of the bayesian alphabet for genomic selectionBMC Bioinformatics, 2011
- Variance component model to account for sample structure in genome-wide association studiesNature Genetics, 2010
- A Hidden Markov Model Combining Linkage and Linkage Disequilibrium Information for Haplotype Reconstruction and Quantitative Trait Locus Fine MappingGenetics, 2010
- Simultaneous Analysis of All SNPs in Genome-Wide and Re-Sequencing Association StudiesPLOS Genetics, 2008
- Bayesian LASSO for Quantitative Trait Loci MappingGenetics, 2008
- Fine Mapping of Quantitative Trait Loci Affecting Female Fertility in Dairy Cattle on BTA03 Using a Dense Single-Nucleotide Polymorphism MapGenetics, 2008
- Principal components analysis corrects for stratification in genome-wide association studiesNature Genetics, 2006
- A unified mixed-model method for association mapping that accounts for multiple levels of relatednessNature Genetics, 2005