Open mesh vs. suture umbilical hernia repair: systematic review and updated trial sequential meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials
- 24 February 2020
- journal article
- review article
- Published by Springer Nature in Hernia
- Vol. 24 (4) , 707-715
Abstract
Purpose To examine the updated evidence on safety, effectiveness, and outcomes of mesh versus suture elective umbilical hernia (UH) repair and to explore the timely tendency variations favouring one treatment over another. Methods MEDLINE and CENTRAL databases were consulted. A systematic review, pairwise meta-analysis, and trial sequential analysis (TSA) were conducted. Results Six RCTs were included for a total of 742 patients. Overall, 383 (51.6%) underwent mesh, while 359 (48.4%) underwent suture repair. The estimated pooled postoperative recurrence RR was 0.27 (95% CI 0.13–0.53; p < 0.001). The TSA showed a statistically significant timely tendency in favour of mesh repair with a boundary cross curve (Z = 1.96) before reaching the information size. The estimated pooled seroma, haematoma, and wound infection RR were 1.45 (p = 0.368), 0.54 (p = 0.196), and 0.71 (p = 0.375), respectively. The TSA for wound-related complications showed partial, non-significant results. Conclusions Elective UH mesh repair seems to be associated with reduced risk of postoperative recurrence compared to simple suture repair with a statistically significant timely trend endorsed by the TSA. Definitive considerations concerning the cumulative effect for seroma, haematoma, and wound infection are premature. Further studies are warranted to endorse these results and deeply investigate the timely tendency variations.Keywords
This publication has 26 references indexed in Scilit:
- The Cochrane Collaboration's tool for assessing risk of bias in randomised trialsBMJ, 2011
- Open intraperitoneal versus retromuscular mesh repair for umbilical hernias less than 3cm diameterThe American Journal of Surgery, 2011
- Trial sequential analysis reveals insufficient information size and potentially false positive results in many meta-analysesJournal of Clinical Epidemiology, 2008
- Comparison of prosthetic mesh repair and tissue repair in the emergency management of incarcerated para-umbilical hernia: a prospective randomized studyHernia, 2007
- Umbilical hernia repair with the prolene hernia systemThe American Journal of Surgery, 2005
- Cumulative meta–analysis: a new tool for detection of temporal trends and publication bias in ecologyProceedings Of The Royal Society B-Biological Sciences, 2004
- Measuring inconsistency in meta-analysesBMJ, 2003
- Quantifying heterogeneity in a meta‐analysisStatistics in Medicine, 2002
- Randomized clinical trial comparing suture and mesh repair of umbilical hernia in adultsBritish Journal of Surgery, 2001
- Meta-analysis in clinical trialsControlled Clinical Trials, 1986