What drives violence against civilians in civil war? Evidence from Guatemala’s conflict archives
- 7 February 2018
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Journal of Peace Research
- Vol. 55 (2) , 222-235
Abstract
Dominant theories of mass violence hold that strategic concerns in civil war drive the deliberate targeting of civilians. However, the causal mechanisms that link strategic objectives to large-scale violence against civilians remain underspecified, and as such the causal logics that underpin each remain blurred. In this article, we identify and explicate four plausible mechanisms that explain why armed groups would target, for strategic purposes, civilians in war. We then turn to the peak period of violence during the Guatemalan armed conflict to assess which mechanisms were most prevalent. Specifically, we leverage unique archival data: 359 pages of military files from Operation Sofía, a month-long counterinsurgent campaign waged in the northwestern Ixil region. Through process tracing of real-time internal communications, we find that state actors most commonly described the civilian population as loyal to rebel forces; violence against civilians was a means to weaken the insurgency. Troops on the ground also depicted the Ixil population as ‘winnable’, which suggests that security forces used violence in this period to shape civilian behavior. These findings are most consistent with the idea that mass violence in this case and period was a coercive instrument to defeat insurgents by punishing civilians for collaboration. The evidence from this period is less consistent with a logic of genocide, in which the purpose of violence would be to destroy ‘unwinnable’ civilian groups. Our analysis illustrates how a mechanism-centered approach based on process tracing of conflict archives can help uncover logics underlying civilian killing.Keywords
This publication has 29 references indexed in Scilit:
- Weakening the EnemyJournal of Conflict Resolution, 2013
- Denial and punishment in the North CaucasusJournal of Peace Research, 2012
- Blood in the Village: A Local-Level Investigation of State MassacresConflict Management and Peace Science, 2012
- “Destroy Them to Save Us”: Theories of Genocide and the Logics of Political ViolenceTerrorism and Political Violence, 2012
- Understanding Process TracingPS: Political Science & Politics, 2011
- Continuation of Politics by Two Means: Direct and Indirect Violence in Civil WarJournal of Conflict Resolution, 2011
- A Global Model for Forecasting Political InstabilityAmerican Journal of Political Science, 2009
- Seeking Safety: Avoiding Displacement and Choosing Destinations in Civil WarsJournal of Peace Research, 2009
- No Lessons Learned from the Holocaust? Assessing Risks of Genocide and Political Mass Murder since 1955American Political Science Review, 2003
- Defining Genocide as a Sociological ConceptCurrent Sociology, 1990