Critical Friendship Circles: the cultural challenge of cool feedback
- 1 July 2011
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Professional Development in Education
- Vol. 37 (3) , 353-372
Abstract
A critical friend is a friend who offers critique on practice. Critical Friendship Circles (CFCs) are groups of critical friends who meet for feedback using a protocol. A study with 95 participants at an American university in Egypt has revealed challenges specific to the culture of most ‘Teaching English as a Foreign Language’ student‐teachers. A longitudinal grounded theory study used reflective essays, surveys, focus groups and transcripts of CFC meetings as data that revealed four theoretical categories. Cultural intolerance to open negativity, fear and/or rejection of giving or receiving cool feedback, uncertainty about and neglect of the use of protocols and appropriate language, but also usefulness in terms of personal and professional growth were revealed. Professionals teaching English to speakers of other languages who are not familiar with western orientations to critique and feedback often reject CFCs from ignorance and fear. A description of the findings and the steps necessary for student‐teachers from a variety of cultural backgrounds to meet the challenges is included.Keywords
This publication has 10 references indexed in Scilit:
- Critical friendship as a contribution to master’s‐level work in an international programme of studyEducational Action Research, 2009
- Critical Friends Groups: The Possibilities and Limitations Embedded in Teacher Professional Communities Aimed at Instructional Improvement and School ReformTeachers College Record: the Voice of Scholarship in Education, 2008
- Professional Development for Language Teachers2005
- No sleeping partners: relationships between head teachers and critical friendsSchool Leadership & Management, 2005
- Can reflective practice be taught?Reflective Practice, 2005
- Developing a Teacher Identity: The Impact of Critical Friends Practice on the Student TeacherEnglish Education, 2002
- An Examination of the Construct of Critical Reflection: Implications for Teacher Education Programming in the 21st CenturyJournal of Teacher Education, 2000
- Consultation Using Critical FriendsNew Directions for Teaching and Learning, 1999
- TESOL and CultureTESOL Quarterly, 1999
- The diverse role of the critical friend in supporting educational action research projectsEducational Action Research, 1997